Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Cannot find function similar to liftM2

Tags:

haskell

monads

myLiftM2 ::  Monad m => (a -> a1 -> m b) -> m a -> m a1 -> m b
myLiftM2 f x y = x >>= (\r1 -> y >>= (\r2 -> f r1 r2))

In liftM2 f return b, but myLiftM2 return m b

like image 999
ais Avatar asked Nov 23 '13 15:11

ais


1 Answers

tl;dr: Use join :: Monad m => m (m a) -> m a since a plain lift will return m (m a). E.g. write

join $ liftM2 f a b

But also...

liftMs can also be written with Applicative -- e.g.

liftM2 a b c   == a <$> b <*> c
liftM3 a b c d == a <$> b <*> c <*> d

etc.

In this case, if you're willing to write in that style, you can write it cleanly and easily:

import Control.Applicative

myLiftM2 :: (Monad m, Applicative m) => (a -> a1 -> m b) -> m a -> m a1 -> m b
myLiftM2 f x y = join $ f <$> x <*> y

Edit:
As Daniel Wagner points out, you can just as easily write

join $ liftM2 a b c

as the equivalent

join $ a <$> b <*> c

My recommendation of the applicative style is for readability and is a separate point.

like image 187
amindfv Avatar answered Sep 30 '22 03:09

amindfv