Best language for Molecular Dynamics Simulator, to be run in production. (Python+Numpy?) [closed]

Question

I need to build a heavy duty molecular dynamics simulator. I am wondering if python+numpy is a good choice. This will be used in production, so I wanted to start with a good language. I am wondering if I should rather start with a functional language like eg.scala. Do we have enough library support for scientific computation in scala? Or any other language/paradigm combination you think is good - and why. If you had actually built something in the past and are talking from experience, please mention it as it will help me with collecting data points.

thanks much!

Answer 1

The high performing MD implementations tend to be decidedly imperative (as opposed to functional) with big arrays of data trumping object-oriented design. I've worked with LAMMPS, and while it has its warts, it does get the job done. A perhaps more appealing option is HOOMD, which has been optimized from the beginning for Nvidia GPUs with CUDA. HOOMD doesn't have all the features of LAMMPS, but the interface seems a bit nicer (it's scriptable from Python) and it's very high performance.

I've actually implemented my own MD code a couple times (Java and Scala) using a high level object oriented design, and have found disappointing performance compared to the popular MD implementations that are heavily tuned and use C++/CUDA. These days, it seems few scientists write their own MD implementations, but it is useful to be able to modify existing ones.