ASP.Net MVC and state - how to keep state between requests

Question

As a fairly experienced ASP.Net developer just recently starting using MVC, I find myself struggling a bit to change my mindset from a traditional "server control and event handler" way of doing things, into the more dynamic MVC way of things. I think I am slowly getting there, but sometimes the MVC "magic" throws me off.

My current scenario is to create a web page that allows the user to browse a local file, upload it to the server and repeat this until he has a list of files to work with. When he is happy with the file list (which will be displayed in a grid on the page), he will click a button to process the files and extract some data that will be stored in a database.

The last part is not so important, right now I am struggling with something as trivial as building up a list of files, and persisting that list between requests. In the traditional approach this would be extremely simple - the data would be persisted in ViewState. But in MVC I need to pass the data between the controller and the views, and I don't fully get how this is supposed to work.

I guess I better post my rather incomplete attempt of coding this to explain the problem.

In order to keep my file list data, I have created a viewmodel that is basically a typed list of files, along with some extra metadata:

public class ImportDataViewModel {     public ImportDataViewModel()     {         Files = new List<ImportDataFile>();     }      public List<ImportDataFile> Files { get; set; } ... 

In the view, I have a form for browsing and uploading the file:

<form action="AddImportFile" method="post" enctype="multipart/form-data">   <label for="file">     Filename:</label>   <input type="file" name="file" id="file" />   <input type="submit" />   </form> 

The view is using the viewmodel as its model:

@model MHP.ViewModels.ImportDataViewModel 

This will send the file to my action:

public ActionResult AddImportFile(HttpPostedFileBase file, ImportDataViewModel importData)     {          if (file.ContentLength > 0)         {             ImportDataFile idFile = new ImportDataFile { File = file };             importData.Files.Add(idFile);         }          return View("DataImport", importData);     } 

This action returns the view for the DataImport page along with the viewmodel instance containing the list of files.

This works nicely up to a certain point, I can browse a file and upload it, and I can see the viewmodel data inside the action, and then also if I put a breakpoint inside the view and debug "this.Model", everything is fine.

But then, if I try to upload another file, when putting a breakpoint inside the AddImportFile action, the importData parameter is empty. So the view is obviously not passing the current instance of its model to the action.

In the MVC samples I have been through, the model instance is "magically" passed to the action method as a parameter, so why is it empty now?

I assume the real problem is my limited understanding of MVC, and that there is probably a very simple solution to this. Anyways, I would be extremely grateful if somebody could point me in the right direction.

Answer 1

It's been some time since I posted the question, which was quite colored by my little experience and knowledge of MVC. Still I received some quite useful input, that eventually led me to find a solution and also gain some insight of MVC.

What threw me off in the first place, was that you could have a controller with a strongly typed object as a parameter, like this:

public ActionResult DoSomething(MyClass myObject)... 

This object originated from the same controller:

... return View(myObject); ... 

This lead me to believe that the object lived throughout these two steps, and that I somehow could expect that you could send it to the view, do something and then "magically" get it back to the controller again.

After reading up about model binding, I understood that this is of course not the case. The view is completely dead and static, and unless you store the information somewhere, it is gone.

Going back to the problem, which was selecting and uploading files from the client, and building up a list of these files to be displayed, I realized that in general there are three ways to store information between requests in MVC:

1. You can store information in form fields in the view, and post it back to the controller later
2. You can persist it in some kind of storage, e.g. a file or a database
3. You can store it in server memory by acessing objects that lives throughout requests, e.g. session variables

In my case, I had basically two types of information to persist: 1. The file metadata (file name, file size etc.) 2. The file content

The "by-the-book" approach would probably be to store the metadata in form fields, and the file contents in a file or in db. But there is also another way. Since I know my files are quite small and there will be only a few of them, and this solution will never be deployed in a server farm or similar, I wanted to explore the #3 option of session variables. The files are also not interesting to persist beyond the session - they are processed and discarded, so I did not want to store them in my db.

After reading this excellent article: Accessing ASP.NET Session Data Using Dynamics

I was convinced. I simply created a sessionbag class as described in the article, and then I could do the following in my controller:

    [HttpPost]     public ActionResult AddImportFile(HttpPostedFileBase file)     {          ImportDataViewModel importData = SessionBag.Current.ImportData;         if (importData == null) importData = new ImportDataViewModel();          if (file == null)             return RedirectToAction("DataImport");          if (file.ContentLength > 0)         {             ImportDataFile idFile = new ImportDataFile { File = file };             importData.Files.Add(idFile);         }          SessionBag.Current.ImportData = importData;          return RedirectToAction("DataImport");     } 

I am fully aware that in most cases, this would be a bad solution. But for the few kb of server memory the files occupy and with the simplicity of it all, I think it worked out very nicely for me.

The additional bonus of using the SessionBag is that if the user entered a different menu item and then came back, the list of files would still be there. This would not be the case e.g. when choosing the form fields/file storage option.

As a final remark, I realize that the SessionBag is very easy to abuse, given the simplicity of use. But if you use it for what it is meant for, namely session data, I think it can be a powerful tool.

Answer 2

Regarding Uploading

1) Maybe consider an AJAX uploader with HTML to allow your user to select multiple files before they are sent to the server. This BlueImp Jquery AJAX file uploader is pretty amazing with a pretty great api: Blueimp Jquery File Upload. It'll allow users to drag and drop or multi select several files and edit the file order, include/exclude etc.. Then when they are happy they can press upload to sent to your controller or upload handler for processing on the server side.

2) You could make every upload persist to the database, though you would be reloading the entire page and writing some extra view model and razor code to achieve the listing effect. This is probably not going to be responsive...

Regarding Keeping State WebForms/MVC

Keeping state between requests is somewhat black magic and voodoo. When going into ASP.NET MVC, go in it understanding that web applications communicate using request and responses. So go in embracing the web as stateless and develop from there! When your model is posted through your controller, it's gone along with any variables in the controller! However before it goes away, you can store its contents in a database for retrieval later.

Web applications cannot keep true state like desktop applications. There are many ways ajax frameworks, and some voodoo tools that people employ to simulate state in the HTTP environment. And a simulation of state is really only a false mimicry of statefulness. ASP.NET Web Forms tries to simulate state as best it can by kind of hiding the stateless nature of HTTP from the developer. You can run into a lot of headache when trying to employ your own AJAX code in tandem with Web Forms markup code and its own Ajax framework.

I'm really glad you're learning MVC

All jokes aside, if you get the MVC/HTTP/Statelessness mentality, it'll be very easy to apply the patterns to other super popular frameworks like Ruby on Rails, SpringMVC (java), Django (python), CakePHP etc... This easy transfer of knowledge will help you become a much better developer and get REALLY good at Ajax.

I'm really glad you're learning MVC 3, I've been with a few internship at some very large firms that had these crazy large ASP.NET Web Forms projects with code flying everywhere just to change a few numerical values in the database (-_-') Felt like I was using scissors to knit a baby's sock. One easy wrong move, and everything broke. It felt like developing in PHP, you come out sweating and not really sure what happened and on what line. It was almost impossible to debug and update.