Ansible SSH private key in source control?

Question

I have been developing an Ansible playbook for a couple of weeks, therefore, my experience with such technology is relatively short. Part of my strategy includes using a custom ansible_ssh_user for provisioning hosts throughout the inventory, however, such user will need its own SSH key pair, which would involve some sort of a plan for holding/storing its correspondent private key. On a production environment, this playbook would be cloned/pulled and run inside a certain playbook node whose role is to provision the rest of the infrastructure.

At first, I was thinking to just put that private key inside the playbook git repository, but I am having second thoughts about it nonetheless, mostly because of somewhat obvious security reasons and common sense around it, hence the reason I need to consult you about this matter.

With this set on the table, here are the follow-up questions:

• In an Ansible-based development environment, is it sane/reasonable to hold a private SSH key in source control?
• Would this practice be advised only for development environments whereas another local git branch inside the playbook node would be then used to hold the actual production SSH private key?
• Would it be better to address this case scenario via Ansible Vault instead?, I have not ever used this before, but regardless of that I cannot yet tell whether this would be a proper case for using it.
• In your experience, what would be your approach around this in a production environment?, what would it be considered as the best practice in this particular scenario?

Answer 1

It's a bad idea to store any kind of plaintext secret in revision control, SSH private keys included. Instead, use ansible-vault to store the private key.

ansible-vault can operate on any file type. Just encrypt the file with

ansible-vault encrypt /path/to/local/private_key 

then install the key:

- name: Install a private SSH key   vars:     source_key: /path/to/local/private_key     dest_key: /path/to/remote/private_key   tasks:   - name: Ensure .ssh directory exists.     file:        dest: "{{ dest_key | dirname }}"       mode: 0700        owner: user        state: directory   - name: Install ssh key     copy:        src: "{{ source_key }}"        dest: "{{ dest_key }}"       mode: 0600       owner: user 

Earlier versions of ansible-vault would only operate on variables defined in var files, so you had to do something like this:

ssh_key: |   -----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY-----   ...   -----END RSA PRIVATE KEY----- key_file: /home/user/.ssh/id_rsa 

Encrypt with ansible-vault:

ansible-vault encrypt /path/to/var_file 

And install the key:

- name: Ensure .ssh directory exists.   file:      dest: "{{ key_file | dirname }}"     mode: 0700      owner: user      state: directory  - name: Install ssh key   copy:      content: "{{ ssh_key }}"      dest: "{{ key_file }}"     mode: 0600     owner: user 

Thanks to all those below who improved the answer with their comments.

Answer 2

Since you are provisioning from scratch, you should generate the private/public key pair on the playbook node and then distribute the public key via the authorized_keys module. This would eliminate the need to store a secret anywhere except on the host where it is needed. Here is a playbook to achieve this, which would be executed on the playbook node:

--- - hosts: 127.0.0.1   sudo: yes   gather_facts: no   tasks:    - name: create ansible_ssh_user locally     user: name=ansible_ssh_user generate_ssh_key=yes ssh_key_bits=2048 ssh_key_file=.ssh/id_rsa    - name: copy the generated public key to an accessible location for the next play     shell: cp ~ansible_ssh_user/.ssh/id_rsa.pub /tmp/ansible_ssh_user.pub  - hosts: all   sudo: yes   gather_facts: no   tasks:    - name: create ansible_ssh_user     user: name=ansible_ssh_user groups=group1,group2    - name: Add RSA public key to the remote host     authorized_key: user=ansible_ssh_user key="{{ lookup('file', '/tmp/ansible_ssh_user.pub') }}"  - hosts: 127.0.0.1   sudo: yes   gather_facts: no   tasks:    - name: remove public key from /tmp     shell: rm /tmp/ansible_ssh_user.pub ...