X-Forwarded-Proto and Flask

Question

I have precisely the same problem described in this SO question and answer. The answer to that question is a nice work around but I don't understand the fundamental problem. Terminating SSL at the load balancer and using HTTP between the load balancer and web/app servers is very common. What piece of the stack is not respecting the X-Forwarded-Proto? Is it werkzeug? Flask? uwsgi?

In my case I'm using an AWS ELB (which sets X-Forwarded-Proto) => Nginx (which forwards along X-Forwarded-Proto to uwsgi). But in the python app I have to subclass Flask Request as described in the question I referenced above.

Since this is such a common deployment scenario, it seems that there should be a better solution. What am I missing?

Answer 1

You are missing the ProxyFix() middleware component. See the Flask Proxy Setups documentation.

There is no need to subclass anything; simply add this middleware component to your WSGI stack:

# Werkzeug 0.15 and newer from werkzeug.middleware.proxy_fix import ProxyFix from flask import Flask   app = Flask(__name__) app.wsgi_app = ProxyFix(app.wsgi_app, x_proto=1) 

If you have Flask installed, you have Werkzeug too, but do pin the version to >=0.15 to get the updated version of ProxyFix (Flask 1.1.0 and newer already use that version).

This component sets the WSGI scheme from the X-Forwarded-Proto header. Do read the Flask documentation I linked you to above about trusting headers and about customising the middleware to your specific situation. Above, I’ve configured it to only look at X-Forwarded-Proto, but the component can handle other X-Forwarded-* configurations too.

The default is to trust one level of X-Forwarded-For, add x_for=0 to the keyword arguments if you want to disable this.

Also note that the functionality of the ProxyFix middleware has been expanded quite significantly in Werkzeug 0.15; in addition to X-Forwarded-Proto, -For, and -Host, the X-Forwarded-Port and -Prefix headers are also consulted, all headers support multiple values.