There're a lot of questions on SO about details of pointer and array declarations in C (and C subset of C++).
I'm more interested in why.
Why do we have to put *, [] in front of every variable when we declare several pointers/arrays in a row?
int *a, *b;
int c[1], d[1];
Why do we have to type out things after/around variable names in function pointers?
void (*foo_ptr)(int, int);
Why do we have this feature that confuses a lot of newcomers, when even compilers recognize and report these things as part of type? Ex: function foo accepts int** but it was given int*
I guess I'm looking for intuition behind it that caused it being created this way, so that I can apply it to my understanding of the language. Right now I just don't see it...
Kernighan and Ritchie write, in The C Programming Language, 1978, page 90:
The declaration of the pointer
pxis new.
int *px;is intended as a mnemonic; it says the combination
*pxis anint, that is, ifpxoccurs in the context*px, it is equivalent to a variable of the typeint. In effect, the syntax of the declaration for a variable mimics the syntax of expressions in which the variable might appear. This reasoning is useful in all cases involving complicated declarations. For example,
double atof(), *dp;says that in an expression
atof()and*dphave values of typedouble.
Thus, we see that, in declarations such as int X, Y, Z, X, Y, and Z give us “pictures” of expressions, such as b, *b, b[10], *b[10], and so on. The actual type for the declared identifier is derived from the picture: Since *b[10] is an int, then b[10] is a pointer to an int, so b is an array of 10 pointers to int.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With