Why Play! framework chose Groovy for template engine

Question

From their website http://www.playframework.org/documentation/1.0/faq

" The biggest CPU consumer in the Play stack at this time is the template engine based on Groovy. But as Play applications are easily scalable, it is not really a problem if you need to serve a very high traffic: you can balance the load between several servers. And we hope for a performance gain at this level with the new JDK7 and its better support of dynamic languages. "

So there are no better choices? What about JSP?

Answer 1

JSP is not feasible as every JSP compiles to a Servlet and the servlet API provides things like the server side session which are not compatible with the RESTful paradigm. We don't want to go back to the dark ages of badly scalable server side sessions, back buttoning problems in the browser, reposts etc.

Japid templates are interesting, but they are not backed by a great community and perhaps didn't even exist at the time play was created (I don't know for sure though). I tried Japid as a replacement for the Groovy templates in my own application and found out in a JMeter test that the benefit would be only marginal, 10% to max. 25% improvement.

I guess in the end it all depends on your scalability requirements and the structure of your pages. I picked the 90% use case of my application and did the test. To me, the little improvement did not justify for the additional costs of the extra dependency (I like to keep dependencies to a minimum for maintainability).

Groovy templates are not bad or slow in general. Use typed variables wherever possible (instead of "def"), even in closures! Keep values of accessed properties in local variables. Do reasonable results paging. Then keep your fingers crossed that GSP might be able to run on groovy++ in the future and you're done ;)

To me, the question would not be why they used groovy in the views. That is, because I rather do miss it so much in the controller layer. Groovy would make coding the controller behaviour a lot easier IMHO.