Why is hasNext() False, but hasNextLine() is True?

Question

Question

How is it that for a scanner object the hasNextLine() method returns true while the hasNext() method returns false?

Note: Based on the input file, the hasNext() method is returning the result as expected; the hasNextLine() does not seem to be returning the correct result.

Code

Here's the code I'm running that's creating the results below:

public void ScannerTest(Reader fileReaderObject){
    Scanner scannerObj = new Scanner(fileReaderObject);

    for(int i = 1; scannerObj.hasNext(); i++){
        System.out.println(i + ": " + scannerObj.next());
        System.out.println("Has next line: " + scannerObj.hasNextLine());
        System.out.println("Has next: " + scannerObj.hasNext());
    }
    System.out.println();

    scannerObj.close();
}

Input File

The following is the actual content of the file that I'm passing to this scanner:

a   3   9
b   3   6
c   3   3
d   2   8
e   2   5
f   2   2
g   1   7
h   1   4
i   1   1

Result

The following is the end of what's printed in the console when I run my code, and includes the portion I can't make sense of:

25: i
Has next line: true
Has next: true
26: 1
Has next line: true
Has next: true
27: 1
Has next line: true
Has next: false

Answer 1

The reason is that hasNext() checks if there are any more non-whitespace characters available. hasNextLine() checks to see if there is another line of text available. Your text file probably has a newline at the end of it so it has another line but no more characters that are not whitespace.

Many text editors automatically add a newline to the end of a file if there isn't one already.

In other words, your input file is not this (the numbers are line numbers):

1. a   3   9
2. b   3   6
3. c   3   3
4. d   2   8
5. e   2   5

It is actually this:

1. a   3   9
2. b   3   6
3. c   3   3
4. d   2   8
5. e   2   5
6. 

Answer 2

You have a single extra newline at the end of your file.

• hasNextLine() checks to see if there is another linePattern in the buffer.
• hasNext() checks to see if there is a parseable token in the buffer, as separated by the scanner's delimiter.

Since the scanner's delimiter is whitespace, and the linePattern is also white space, it is possible for there to be a linePattern in the buffer but no parseable tokens.

Typically, the most common way to deal with this issue by always calling nextLine() after parsing all the tokens (e.g. numbers) in each line of your text. You need to do this when using Scanner when reading a user's input too from System.in. To advance the scanner past this whitespace delimiter, you must use scanner.nextLine() to clear the line delimiter. See: Using scanner.nextLine()

---

Appendix:

LinePattern is defined to be a Pattern that matches this:

private static final String LINE_SEPARATOR_PATTERN =
                                       "\r\n|[\n\r\u2028\u2029\u0085]";
private static final String LINE_PATTERN = ".*("+LINE_SEPARATOR_PATTERN+")|.+$";

The default token delimiter is this Pattern:

private static Pattern WHITESPACE_PATTERN = Pattern.compile(
                                            "\\p{javaWhitespace}+");

Answer 3

Short answer

You have an empty line at the end of the file.

---

Reason for the empty line

If you take your content and save it for example into a txt file, some editors will add an empty new line to your file.

The editors behave this way, because this is part of the POSIX standard:

3.206 Line

A sequence of zero or more non- characters plus a terminating character.

This topic has been discussed in this thread.

---

Java Scanner documentation

Here is the documentation from the Java 8 Scanner class.

hasNext()

Returns true if this scanner has another token in its input.

---

hasNextLine()

Returns true if there is another line in the input of this scanner.

---

Reason for the Java code behavior

Because of the above described facts, hasNextLine() will return true, but hasNext() cannot find anything, which it can recognize as Token and returns therefore false.

For additional infos see durron597 post.

Answer 4

You are consuming the value of next(), but asking for hasNext() and hasNextLine(). next(), per default, returns everything to the next whitespace(). So you are iterating through all whitespace seperated strings, and after each of them you are asking about the nextLine().

i 1 1 -> hasNextLine()? True. hasNext()? Also true.

1 1 -> hasNextLine()? True. hasNext()? Also true (still a whitespace left)

1 -> hasNextLine()? True (Line Seperator, probably). haxNext? False, no whitespace anymore.