Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Why does EF 5.x use plural name for table?

I've had some experiences in ORM framework such as Hibernate, even Entity Framework 3.0.

By default, those frameworks use singular name for table. For example, class User will map to table User.

But when I migrate to EF 5.x by using Visual Studio 2012, it uses plural name and causes many errors unless I manually map that class by using TableAttribute as:

[Table("User")]
public class User {
    // ...
}

Without TableAttribute, if I have a DbContext as below:

public CustomContext : DbContext {
    // ...
    public DbSet<User> Users { get; set; }
}

Then calling:

var list = db.Users.ToList();

The generated sql looks like:

Select [Extent1].[Username] From [Users] as [Extent1]

Therefore, the error will occur because I don't have any table named Users. Futhermore, I refer to name tables in singular form to plural form. You can see why in this link

I wonder why Microsoft implement EF 5.x that way rather than same to EF 3.0?

Updated:

We can tell EF not use pluralized name by using this code in the context class:

protected override void OnModelCreating(DbModelBuilder modelBuilder)
{
    modelBuilder.Conventions.Remove<PluralizingTableNameConvention>();

    base.OnModelCreating(modelBuilder);
}

Even if EF tool generates pluralized name, it should keep the mappings to the original database, shouldn't it? Because some users might want to change a few name of fields on their class. EF 3.0 works well, but EF 5.x does not.

Guys, can you give my a reason, please!

like image 608
Tu Tran Avatar asked Dec 20 '12 09:12

Tu Tran


1 Answers

That convention is defined in the PluralizingTableNameConvention convention defined by default in the DbModelBuilder.Conventions

If you want to exclude it from all tables, you can use the code from this question.

Why this is done the way it is, I do not know, but I must say that I am, personally, in the camp that thinks that table names should be pluralized :)

Of the example databases provided with an SQL Server instance, Northwind has plurals, and AdventureWorks uses a singular form, so at best, there is no established standard. I've had quite a few discussion for or against each one, but one thing that everybody can agree on is that when once pick a naming strategy, you should stick with it.

like image 87
SWeko Avatar answered Oct 14 '22 13:10

SWeko