Why do I need a mocking framework for my unittests?

Question

Recently there has been quite some hype around all the different mocking frameworks in the .NET world. I still haven't quite grasped what is so great about them. It doesn't seem to be to hard to write the mocking objects I need myself. Especially with the help of Visual Studio I quickly can write a class that implements the interface I want to mock (it auto-generates almost everything for me) and then write an implementation for the method(s) I need for my test. Done! Why going through the hassle of understanding a mocking framework for the sole purpose of saving a few lines of code. Or is a mocking framework not only about saving lines of code?

Answer 1

Once I finally got the hang of mock objects, I realized that they're essential for unit testing for the same reason that double blind testing or control groups are essential for scientific trials: they isolate what you're actually testing.

If you're testing a class which has quite a bit of interaction via other interfaces, you not only save the lines of code on having to mock each and every interface, but you also gain the ability to do things like "throw an exception if an unexpected method is called" or "exception if these methods are called out of order". You can get remarkably sophisticated with mock frameworks, and though I'll quickly admit there's a large learning curve, when you get up to speed they'll help make your unit tests more thorough without being bloated.

Answer 2

You actually identified one of the key points of a mock framework in your question. The fact that you code the mocks yourself is not something the developer should be concerned with. The mocking frameworks give you implementations of interfaces programatically, plus they are functional (based on your setup of the mock).

What do you do if you are testing an ICustomerDAO, for example, and you want to test some method 14 times each with different outcomes? Implement 14 different classes manually? I doubt that anyone would want to do that.

Mocks give you the power to define what will happen with parts of your classes when you are not concerned with whether or not they will actually work, like throwing exceptions whenever you want them to, returning zero results and making sure you handle that correctly, etc...

They are a great unit testing tool.