When to use -retainCount?

Question

I would like to know in what situation did you use -retainCount so far, and eventually the problems that can happen using it.

Thanks.

Answer 1

You should never use -retainCount, because it never tells you anything useful. The implementation of the Foundation and AppKit/UIKit frameworks is opaque; you don't know what's being retained, why it's being retained, who's retaining it, when it was retained, and so on.

For example:

• You'd think that [NSNumber numberWithInt:1] would have a retainCount of 1. It doesn't. It's 2.
• You'd think that @"Foo" would have a retainCount of 1. It doesn't. It's 1152921504606846975.
• You'd think that [NSString stringWithString:@"Foo"] would have a retainCount of 1. It doesn't. Again, it's 1152921504606846975.

Basically, since anything can retain an object (and therefore alter its retainCount), and since you don't have the source to most of the code that runs an application, an object's retainCount is meaningless.

If you're trying to track down why an object isn't getting deallocated, use the Leaks tool in Instruments. If you're trying to track down why an object was deallocated too soon, use the Zombies tool in Instruments.

But don't use -retainCount. It's a truly worthless method.

edit

Please everyone go to http://bugreport.apple.com and request that -retainCount be deprecated. The more people that ask for it, the better.

edit #2

As an update,[NSNumber numberWithInt:1] now has a retainCount of 9223372036854775807. If your code was expecting it to be 2, your code has now broken.

Answer 2

NEVER!

Seriously. Just don't do it.

Just follow the Memory Management Guidelines and only release what you alloc, new or copy (or anything you called retain upon originally).

@bbum said it best here on SO, and in even more detail on his blog.

Answer 3

Autoreleased objects are one case where checking -retainCount is uninformative and potentially misleading. The retain count tells you nothing about how many times -autorelease has been called on an object and therefore how many time it will be released when the current autorelease pool drains.