What's the most elegant way to combine optionals?

Question

Here's what I've got so far:

Optional<Foo> firstChoice = firstChoice(); Optional<Foo> secondChoice = secondChoice(); return Optional.ofNullable(firstChoice.orElse(secondChoice.orElse(null))); 

This strikes me as both hideous and wasteful. If firstChoice is present I am needlessly computing secondChoice.

There's also a more efficient version:

Optional<Foo> firstChoice = firstChoice(); if(firstChoice.isPresent()) {  return firstChoice; } else {  return secondChoice(); } 

Here I can't chain some mapping function to the end without either duplicating the mapper or declaring another local variable. All of this makes the code more complicated than the actual problem being solved.

I'd much rather be writing this:

return firstChoice().alternatively(secondChoice()); 

However Optional::alternatively obviously doesn't exist. Now what?

Answer 1

Try this:

firstChoice().map(Optional::of)              .orElseGet(this::secondChoice); 

The map method gives you an Optional<Optional<Foo>>. Then, the orElseGet method flattens this back to an Optional<Foo>. The secondChoice method will only be evaluated if firstChoice() returns the empty optional.

Answer 2

Maybe something like this:

Optional<String> finalChoice = Optional.ofNullable(firstChoice()     .orElseGet(() -> secondChoice()     .orElseGet(() -> null))); 

From: Chaining Optionals in Java 8