Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

What's the difference between LazyList and Stream in Scala?

I noticed that Stream is deprecated in Scala 2.13 and they suggest using LazyList. They also say "Use LazyList (which is fully lazy) instead of Stream (which has a lazy tail only)".
What does it exactly mean ? Why did they deprecate Stream ?

like image 778
Michael Avatar asked Feb 08 '20 15:02

Michael


2 Answers

NthPortal, a contributor to LazyList, states in Update and improve LazyList docs #7842

The key difference between LazyList and Stream - and its key feature - is that whether or not it is lazy is evaluated lazily. I'm not sure how best to convey that.

jwvh states in related question

Stream elements are realized lazily except for the 1st (head) element. That was seen as a deficiency.

Scala 2.13 release notes state

immutable.LazyList replaces immutable.Stream. Stream had different laziness behavior and is now deprecated. (#7558, #7000)

like image 173
Mario Galic Avatar answered Oct 24 '22 13:10

Mario Galic


As per the blog post:

LazyList Is Preferred Over Stream

Stream is deprecated in favor of LazyList. As its name suggests, a LazyList is a linked list whose elements are lazily evaluated. An important semantic difference with Stream is that in LazyList both the head and the tail are lazy, whereas in Stream only the tail is lazy.

Also in the Stream documentation:

Deprecated (Since version 2.13.0)

Use LazyList (which is fully lazy) instead of Stream (which has a lazy tail only)

like image 36
psyanite Avatar answered Oct 24 '22 13:10

psyanite