Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

What's the C# equivalent of Java's Class<X> type?

Tags:

c#

generics

In Java, it's convenient for Class to have the generic parameter, X. But C#'s Type class doesn't have this.

So in C#, how does one do the equivalent of the following Java code?:

public <X> X methodThatReturns(Class<X> clazz) { ... }

There doesn't seem to be a way in C# to connect that return values, and the passed Type.

Clarification
Several answers are suggesting the method parameter isn't necessary, because the method could simply be defined as methodThatReturns<X>().

But if you do have some unknown Type variable, t, there's basically no way to call such a generic method so that it will return an object of Type t?

In Java, you're free to pass around Class<X> variables without losing the type information, but it seems that in C# if you pass around the equivalent Type variables, you can run into limitations, because you can't use them when you need to call generic methods.

like image 885
slattery Avatar asked Apr 19 '11 20:04

slattery


3 Answers

public X methodThatReturns<X>(Class<X> clazz) { ... }

Also keep in mind that in C# there is no type erasure so you can do things like typeof(T) without worries in case Class is meant to be the java "Class" object rather than a "some class" placeholder:

public X methodThatReturns<X>(X value)
{
    Type x = typeof(X); // that's fine
    if (value is SomeType) { } // that's fine too    
    return (X)someObject; // I think you get the point
}

Edit:

Again, since the generic type information is not lost after compilation you don't need to pass in the type explicitly:

public X methodThatReturns<X>()
{
    Type xType = typeof(X); // Type is to C#/.Net what Class<X> is to Java.
}
like image 70
Ivan Zlatev Avatar answered Sep 29 '22 23:09

Ivan Zlatev


In C# it would be

public X methodThatReturns<X>() { ... }

and you can get type of X using typeof(X) instead of using the parameter clazz

like image 23
Bala R Avatar answered Sep 29 '22 23:09

Bala R


I'm not 100% up on Java generics... Are you trying to declare a method that returns the same type as it was passed?

public T MethodThatReturns<T>(T input) { ... }

This method will be generic on any type, and return the same type it was passed. You can call this using:

AnyTypeAtAll foo = new AnyTypeAtAll();
AnyTypeAtAll bar = MethodThatReturns(foo);

Note that there's no <AnyTypeAtAll> on the call to MethodThatReturns, the compiler can figure it out given the parameter you passed. However, note that it's the compiler doing that, not runtime, so it'll only use the type of variable foo, not the type of object that foo points to.


On the other hand, if that's Java syntax for a method that takes no 'real' parameters, then simply:

public T MethodThatReturns<T>()
{
    Type clazz = typeof(T);
    ....
}

Within this method, you can treat T the same as you would any other class, and it will refer specifically to the type that the method was called with, not to object or anything like that. You may want to put where T : class to allow comparison to null in that method (which does prevent you from using int as the generic type), or where T : new() to restrict the generic type to have a default constructor, so you can do T foo = new T();

like image 24
David Yaw Avatar answered Sep 29 '22 22:09

David Yaw