Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

What language do they build other languages with?

What language is used to build low level languages like c++ and java?

How could you build the first language with no language?

like image 376
ajsie Avatar asked Jan 10 '10 02:01

ajsie


4 Answers

In the context of compilers, this operation is often called bootstrapping. In particular, see the "Chicken and egg problem" section for a direct answer to your question.

The very first compiler would have been hand-written in assembly language. If your next question is "how was the first assembler written?" then the answer would be that the first assembler was hand-written in binary machine code, possibly with front panel toggle switches. This is undoubtedly a simplification of what really happened, but the concept is the same.

There is also an excellent article titled Reflections on Trusting Trust by Ken Thompson about the risks of using a compiler for a language to build the compiler for that language.

like image 88
Greg Hewgill Avatar answered Oct 17 '22 19:10

Greg Hewgill


You don't build a language, but you build a compiler or an interpreter ... and for this you can choose any language even the language you want to compile ...

The first self-hosting compiler — capable of compiling its own source code in a high-level language — was created for Lisp ... Since the 1970s it has become common practice to implement a compiler in the language it compiles, although both Pascal and C have been popular choices for implementation language. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compiler

like image 28
wj. Avatar answered Oct 17 '22 19:10

wj.


Much of this kind of thing is done in C.

The first C compiler was not written in C; it was PDP-11 assembler. Other early C compilers have been written in various assembler languages.

But all subsequent C compilers actually are written in C, based on an early "Portable C Compiler". Yes, it's circular. But the version x compiler can be used to build the version x+1 compiler.

like image 6
S.Lott Avatar answered Oct 17 '22 18:10

S.Lott


I think the key insight to your question is the notion of boot-strapping. The link will describe how a language can self-host.

It is relatively common in the Lisp community. e.g. Some university classes will use Scheme to write a language subset (this is not a compiler class activity).

That said, many compilers are written in other languages. For example, PUGS (Perl 6) is written in Haskell. Ruby is available in C or Java (as JRuby).

like image 4
Michael Easter Avatar answered Oct 17 '22 18:10

Michael Easter