Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

What is the point of Convert.ToDateTime(bool)?

Tags:

c#

.net

datetime

I was doing some type conversion routines last night for a system I am working on. One of the conversions involves turning string values into their DateTime equivalents.

While doing this, I noticed that the Convert.ToDateTime() method had an overload which accepted a boolean parameter.

First question? Under what circumstances could this ever be useful?

I went a little further and tried to execute the method in QuickWatch. Either way ( true or false ), the routine returns an InvalidCastException.

Second question? Why is this method even here?

EDIT

Thanks for the answers, guys. I can see how it makes sense from a contractual point of view, but it does seem odd that the core framework includes methods that:-

  • Can never work
  • Worse, will actually throw an exception when someone tries to call it.

It's a bit like someone making a car loaded with controls that actively stop your vehicle from working when used.

like image 782
Paul Alan Taylor Avatar asked Apr 22 '10 09:04

Paul Alan Taylor


2 Answers

It makes sense because ToDateTime is part of the IConvertible interface implemented by bool. If you look in reflector you will see that it throws an InvalidCastException.

Update (from Convert):

public static DateTime ToDateTime(bool value)
{
    return ((IConvertible) value).ToDateTime(null);
}
like image 129
Klaus Byskov Pedersen Avatar answered Sep 21 '22 11:09

Klaus Byskov Pedersen


I think it's there for completeness and that you get an explicit InvalidCastException when calling Convert.ToDateTime with an object that is a bool.

If you look at all the members of Convert, you can see that overloads have been included to accept all the basic types for conversion to each of the other basic types, with InvalidCastExceptions being thrown when there is no sensible conversion.

I guess they thought this would be more meaningful than just not having the overloads there at all.

like image 22
DanK Avatar answered Sep 23 '22 11:09

DanK