What is the difference between images in 'P' and 'L' mode in PIL?

Question

According to https://pillow.readthedocs.io/en/3.1.x/handbook/concepts.html#concept-modes,

1. What are the difference between them?
2. Can we convert from one to another?
3. What are the examples of image for both mode?

Answer 1

• Normally, images are RGB, which means they have 3 channels, one for red, one for green and one for blue. That normally means that each pixel takes 3 bytes of storage, one for red, one for green and one for blue.

• If you have a P mode image, that means it is palettised. That means there is a palette with up to 256 different colours in it, and instead of storing 3 bytes for R, G and B for each pixel, you store 1 byte which is the index into the palette. This confers both advantages and disadvantages. The advantage is that your image requires 1/3 of the space in memory and on disk. The disadvantage is that it can only represent 256 unique colours - so you may get banding or artefacts.

• If you have an L mode image, that means it is a single channel image - normally interpreted as greyscale. The L means that is just stores the Luminance. It is very compact, but only stores a greyscale, not colour.

---

You can tell which mode your image has by looking at:

image.mode 

If your image is palettised it will be P, or PA if palettised with an alpha channel as well. If your image is greyscale it will be L, or LA if greyscale with alpha channel.

You convert between them using the convert(mode) function, e.g. to go to RGB mode, use:

image.convert('RGB') 

---

I used the word "normally" quite a lot! Why? Because you can do abnormal things!

• You can store a grey-looking image in an RGB format. All you do, is make the red component equal to the green component equal to the blue component (R=G=B) and it will appear grey but be stored in an inefficient RGB format that takes 3x the space it might otherwise need to.

• You can store a grey-looking image in a P format, you just make sure all the palette entries have the R=G=B.

---

Here's the kicker... if you want and expect an RGB image, you should just convert to RGB on opening:

im = Image.open("image.jpg").convert('RGB') 

that way you will never have problems with GIF files (which are always palettised) nor with PNG files which can be palettised and can be greyscale or RGB. You will not normally get problems with JPEG images because they are pretty much always RGB anyway.

---

Here's an example to demonstrate. Start with this red-blue gradient image:

Let's use IPython to look at in RGB space. First, look at the Red channel:

In [21]: im = Image.open('a.png').convert('RGB')  In [22]: np.array(im.getchannel(0)) Out[22]:  array([[255, 255, 255, ..., 255, 255, 255],        [255, 255, 255, ..., 255, 255, 255],        [254, 254, 254, ..., 254, 254, 254],        ...,        [  1,   1,   1, ...,   1,   1,   1],        [  0,   0,   0, ...,   0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0, ...,   0,   0,   0]], dtype=uint8) 

Notice it has 255 at the top because it is red, and 0 at the bottom because there is no red there.

Now let's look at the Green channel, it is 0 everywhere because there is no green.

In [23]: np.array(im.getchannel(1)) Out[23]:  array([[0, 0, 0, ..., 0, 0, 0],        [0, 0, 0, ..., 0, 0, 0],        [0, 0, 0, ..., 0, 0, 0],        ...,        [0, 0, 0, ..., 0, 0, 0],        [0, 0, 0, ..., 0, 0, 0],        [0, 0, 0, ..., 0, 0, 0]], dtype=uint8) 

And finally, let's look at the Blue channel. It is 0 at the top where the image is pure Red and 255 at the bottom where the image is pure Blue.

In [24]: np.array(im.getchannel(2)) Out[24]:  array([[  0,   0,   0, ...,   0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0, ...,   0,   0,   0],        [  1,   1,   1, ...,   1,   1,   1],        ...,        [254, 254, 254, ..., 254, 254, 254],        [255, 255, 255, ..., 255, 255, 255],        [255, 255, 255, ..., 255, 255, 255]], dtype=uint8) 

Now let's look at the same image in palette mode.

# Convert to palette mode im = Image.open('a.png').convert('P')  # Extract the palette and reshape as 256 entries of 3 RGB bytes each In [27]: np.array(im.getpalette()).reshape(256,3) Out[27]:  array([[  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [  0,   0,   0],        [ 51,   0,   0],        [102,   0,   0],        [153,   0,   0],        [204,   0,   0],        [255,   0,   0],      <--- entry 15 = rgb(255,0,0) = Red        [  0,  51,   0],        [ 51,  51,   0],        [102,  51,   0],        [153,  51,   0],        [204,  51,   0],        [255,  51,   0],        [  0, 102,   0],        [ 51, 102,   0],        [102, 102,   0],        [153, 102,   0],        [204, 102,   0],        [255, 102,   0],        [  0, 153,   0],        [ 51, 153,   0],        [102, 153,   0],        [153, 153,   0],        [204, 153,   0],        [255, 153,   0],        [  0, 204,   0],        [ 51, 204,   0],        [102, 204,   0],        [153, 204,   0],        [204, 204,   0],        [255, 204,   0],        [  0, 255,   0],        [ 51, 255,   0],        [102, 255,   0],        [153, 255,   0],        [204, 255,   0],        [255, 255,   0],        ...        ... up to 256 entries 

Now get the indices into the palette:

In [28]: np.array(im.getchannel(0)) Out[28]:  array([[ 15,  15,  15, ...,  15,  15,  15],        [ 15,  15,  15, ...,  15,  15,  15],        [ 15,  15,  15, ...,  15,  15,  15],        ...,        [190, 190, 190, ..., 190, 190, 190],        [190, 190, 190, ..., 190, 190, 190],        [190, 190, 190, ..., 190, 190, 190]], dtype=uint8) 

Now you can see that the top row of the image has palette index 15, which, if you look it up in the preceding palette, you will see is Red.

Now let's look at the same image in L mode - remember L means "Luminance" which is just a fancy way of saying "brightness" on a scale of black to white, i.e. greyscale :

# Open into greyscale, or L mode In [1]: im = Image.open('a.png').convert('L')  # Dump the pixels In [2]: np.array(im.getchannel(0)) Out[2]:  array([[76, 76, 76, ..., 76, 76, 76],        [76, 76, 76, ..., 76, 76, 76],        [76, 76, 76, ..., 76, 76, 76],        ...,        [29, 29, 29, ..., 29, 29, 29],        [29, 29, 29, ..., 29, 29, 29],        [29, 29, 29, ..., 29, 29, 29]], dtype=uint8) 

So, now the top row of the image is 76 and the bottom row is 29. What are those? Well, the formula for converting RGB to L is:

L = R * 299/1000 + G * 587/1000 + B * 114/1000

So, in the top row, R=255, G=0, B=0, so the Luminance has become:

L = 255 * 299/1000 + 0 + 0  L = 76 

And on the bottom row, R=0, G=0, B=255, so the Luminance has become:

L = 0 + 0 + 255 * 114/1000 L = 29 

Keywords: Python, PIL, Pillow, palette, image processing, prime.

Answer 2

"L" mode maps to black and white pixels (and in between). "P" mode maps with a color palette. You can convert image to one of these modes.

from PIL import Image  im = Image.open("im.jpg") im_l = im.convert('L') im_p = im.convert('P')  im.show() im_l.show() im_p.show()