What is the difference between git pull and git fetch + git rebase?

Question

Another question says that git pull is like a git fetch + git merge.

But what is the difference between git pull and git fetch + git rebase?

Answer 1

It should be pretty obvious from your question that you're actually just asking about the difference between git merge and git rebase.

So let's suppose you're in the common case - you've done some work on your master branch, and you pull from origin's, which also has done some work. After the fetch, things look like this:

- o - o - o - H - A - B - C (master)                \                 P - Q - R (origin/master) 

If you merge at this point (the default behavior of git pull), assuming there aren't any conflicts, you end up with this:

- o - o - o - H - A - B - C - X (master)                \             /                 P - Q - R --- (origin/master) 

If on the other hand you did the appropriate rebase, you'd end up with this:

- o - o - o - H - P - Q - R - A' - B' - C' (master)                           |                           (origin/master) 

The content of your work tree should end up the same in both cases; you've just created a different history leading up to it. The rebase rewrites your history, making it look as if you had committed on top of origin's new master branch (R), instead of where you originally committed (H). You should never use the rebase approach if someone else has already pulled from your master branch.

Finally, note that you can actually set up git pull for a given branch to use rebase instead of merge by setting the config parameter branch.<name>.rebase to true. You can also do this for a single pull using git pull --rebase.

Answer 2

TLDR:

git pull is like running git fetch then git merge
git pull --rebase is like git fetch then git rebase

In reply to your first statement,

git pull is like a git fetch + git merge.

"In its default mode, git pull is shorthand for git fetch followed by git merge FETCH_HEAD" More precisely, git pull runs git fetch with the given parameters and then calls git merge to merge the retrieved branch heads into the current branch"

(Ref: https://git-scm.com/docs/git-pull)

For your second statement/question:

'But what is the difference between git pull VS git fetch + git rebase'

Again, from same source:
git pull --rebase

"With --rebase, it runs git rebase instead of git merge."

Now, if you wanted to ask

'the difference between merge and rebase'

that is answered here too:
https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2/Git-Branching-Rebasing
(the difference between altering the way version history is recorded)