What does std::vector look like in memory?

Question

I read that std::vector should be contiguous. My understanding is, that its elements should be stored together, not spread out across the memory. I have simply accepted the fact and used this knowledge when for example using its data() method to get the underlying contiguous piece of memory.

However, I came across a situation, where the vector's memory behaves in a strange way:

std::vector<int> numbers; std::vector<int*> ptr_numbers; for (int i = 0; i < 8; i++) {     numbers.push_back(i);     ptr_numbers.push_back(&numbers.back()); } 

I expected this to give me a vector of some numbers and a vector of pointers to these numbers. However, when listing the contents of the ptr_numbers pointers, there are different and seemingly random numbers, as though I am accessing wrong parts of memory.

I have tried to check the contents every step:

for (int i = 0; i < 8; i++) {     numbers.push_back(i);     ptr_numbers.push_back(&numbers.back());     for (auto ptr_number : ptr_numbers)        std::cout << *ptr_number << std::endl;     std::cout << std::endl; } 

The result looks roughly like this:

1  some random number 2  some random number some random number 3 

So it seems as though when I push_back() to the numbers vector, its older elements change their location.

So what does it exactly mean, that std::vector is a contiguous container and why do its elements move? Does it maybe store them together, but moves them all together, when more space is needed?

Edit: Is std::vector contiguous only since C++17? (Just to keep the comments on my previous claim relevant to future readers.)

Answer 1

It roughly looks like this (excuse my MS Paint masterpiece):

The std::vector instance you have on the stack is a small object containing a pointer to a heap-allocated buffer, plus some extra variables to keep track of the size and and capacity of the vector.

---

So it seems as though when I push_back() to the numbers vector, its older elements change their location.

The heap-allocated buffer has a fixed capacity. When you reach the end of the buffer, a new buffer will be allocated somewhere else on the heap and all the previous elements will be moved into the new one. Their addresses will therefore change.

---

Does it maybe store them together, but moves them all together, when more space is needed?

Roughly, yes. Iterator and address stability of elements is guaranteed with std::vector only if no reallocation takes place.

---

I am aware, that std::vector is a contiguous container only since C++17

The memory layout of std::vector hasn't changed since its first appearance in the Standard. ContiguousContainer is just a "concept" that was added to differentiate contiguous containers from others at compile-time.