I am looking for a list of the allowed characters in a clojure keyword. Specifically I am interested to know if any of the following characters are allowed: -
_
/
.
I am not a java programmer, so I would not know the underlying ramifications if any. I don't know if the clojure keyword is mapped to a java keyword if there is such a thing.
Edit:
When I initially composed this answer, I was probably a little too heavily invested in the question of "what can you get away with?" In fairness to myself though, the keyword admissibility issue appears to be unsettled still. So:
First, a little about keywords, for new readers:
:foo
, have no namespace component. Qualified keywords look like :foo/bar
where the part prior to the slash is the namespace, ostensibly. Keywords can't be referred, and can be given a non-existent namespace, so their namespace behaviour is different from other Clojure objects.:foo
, or by the keyword
function, which is (keyword name-str)
or (keyword ns name)
.What is officially permitted?
According to the reader documentation a single slash is permitted, a no periods in the name, and all rules to do with symbols.
What is actually permitted?
More or less anything but spaces seem to be permitted in the reader. For instance,
user> :-_./asdfgse/aser/se
:-_./asdfgse/aser/se
Appears to be legal. The namespace for the above keyword is:
user> (namespace :-_./asdfgse/aser/se)
"-_./asdfgse/aser"
So the namespace appears to consist of everything prior to the last forward slash.
The keyword
function is even more permissive:
user> (keyword "////+" "/////")
:////+//////
user> (namespace (keyword "////+" "/////"))
"////+"
And similarly, spaces are fine too if you use the keyword
function. I'm not sure exactly what limitations are placed on Unicode characters, but the REPL doesn't appear to complain when I put in arbitrary characters.
What's likely to happen in the future:
There have been some rumblings about validating keywords as they are interned. Supposedly one of the longest open clojure tickets is concerned with validation of keywords. So the keyword function may cease to be so permissive in the future, though that seems to be up in the air. See the assembla ticket and google group discussion.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With