Using google maps from a .NET desktop application

Question

A interesting thread at : http://greatmaps.codeplex.com/discussions/252531 Apparently google has asked the developer to remove support for google maps from the open source API because it uses undocumented methods (which are obviously quite openly documented by third parties all over the internet).

Two questions:

Is there no legal way to make google maps applications without using the provided javascript / flex apis?

If so aren't there a lot of applications out there that do this illegally? (even mapinfo 10 has google maps support)

Answer 1

PS: Found the documentation for this : http://code.google.com/apis/maps/terms.html

10.1 Restrictions on How You May Use the Maps API(s). Except as explicitly permitted in Section 8 (Licenses from Google to You) or the Maps APIs Documentation, you must not (nor may you permit anyone else to) do any of the following:

• 10.1.1. General Restrictions.

(a) No Access to Maps API(s) except through the Service. You must not access or use the Maps API(s) or any Content through any technology or means other than those provided in the Service, or through other explicitly authorized means Google may designate. For example, you must not access map tiles or imagery through interfaces or channels (including undocumented Google interfaces) other than the Maps API(s).

So any application that doesn't either call the javascript / flex / webservice api is illegally using it UNLESS google approved the application (like the iphone maps application). This is bad for small time developers.

Answer 2

Based on my non-legal background, with some small experience working with the Google API, and google itself, I would say:

1. No there is no legal way, unless you can get Google to agree, which they won't.
2. Yes there are lots of applications which do this illegally, however there are also some which do so legally.