Unit testing programs that mostly interact with external resources

Question

I would like to start doing more unit testing in my applications, but it seems to me that most of the stuff I do is just no suitable to be unit tested. I know how unit tests are supposed to work in textbook examples, but in real world applications they do not seem of much use.

Some applications I write have very simple logic and complex interactions with things that are outside my control. For instance I would like to write a daemon which reacts to signals sent by some applications, and changes some user settings in the OS. I can see three difficulties:

• first I have to be able to talk with the applications and be notified of their events;
• then I need to interact with OS whenever I receive a signal, in order to change the appropriate user settings;
• finally all of this should work as a daemon.

All these things are potentially delicate: I will have to browse possibly complex APIs and I may introduce bugs, say by misinterpreting some parameters. What can unit testing do for me? I can mock both the external application and the OS, and check that given a signal from the application, I will call the appropriate API method on the OS. This is... well, the trivial part of the application.

Actually most of the things I do involve interaction with databases, the filesystem or other applications, and these are the most delicate parts.

For another example look at my build tool PHPmake. I would like to refactor it, as it is not very well-written, but I fear to do this as I have no tests. So I would like to add some. The point is that the things which may be broken by refactoring may not be caught by unit tests:

• One of things to do is deciding which things are to be built and which one are already up to date, and this depends on the time of last modification of the files. This time is actually changed by external processes, when some build command is fired.
• I want to be sure that the output of external processes is displayed correctly. Sometimes the buikd commands require some input, and that should be also managed correctly. But I do not know a priori which processes will be ran - it may be anything.
• Some logic is involved in pattern matching, and this may seem to be testable part. But the functions which do the pattern matching use (ni addition to their own logic) the PHP function glob, which works with the filesystem. If I just mock a tree in place of the actual filesystem, glob will not work.

I could go on with more examples, but the point is the following. Unless I have some delicate algorithms, most of what I do involves interaction with external resources, and this is not suitable for unit testing. More that this, often this interaction is actually the non-trivial part. Still many people see unit testing as a basic tool. What am I missing? How can I learn be a better tester?

Answer 1

I think you open a number of issues in your question.

Firstly, when your application integrates with external environments such as OS, other threads, etc. then you have to separate (1) the logic that is tied in with the external enviroment and (2) your business-code.. that is, the stuff your application does. This is no different to how you would separate GUI and SERVER in an application (or web application).

Secondly, you ask if you should test simple logic. I'd say, it depends. Often simple fetch/store functionality is nice to have tests for. It's like the foundation of your application.. hence its important. Other business stuff built upon your foundation that is very simple, you may easily find yourself both feeling that you are wasting your time, and mostly you are :-)

Thirdly, refactory an existing program and testing it in its existing state may be a problem. If your PHP program produces a set of files on the basis of some input, well, maybe thats your entry point to tests are. Sure the tests may be high-level, but it's an easy way to ensure that after the refactoring, your program produces the same output. Hence, aim for higher-level tests in that situation in the start phase of your refactoring efforts.

I'd like to recommend some literature, but I can only come up with one title. "Working Effectively with Legacy Code" By Micheal Feathers. It's a good start. Another would be "xUnit Test Patterns: Refactoring Test Code" by Gerard Meszaros (although that book is much more sloppy and FULL of copy paste text).