Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Type Hinting for objects of type that's being defined [duplicate]

I get the error:

NameError: name 'OrgUnit' is not defined
class OrgUnit(object):

    def __init__(self,
                 an_org_name: str,
                 its_parent_org_unit: OrgUnit= None
                 ):
        self.org_unit_name = an_org_name
        self.parent_org_unit = its_parent_org_unit

    def __str__(self):
        if self.parent_org_unit:
            parent_org_unit_name = self.parent_org_unit.__str__()
            return parent_org_unit_name + "->" + self.org_unit_name
        else:
            return self.org_unit_name


if __name__ == '__main__':
    ibm_worldwide = OrgUnit("IBM_Worldwide")
    ibm_usa = OrgUnit("IBM_USA", ibm_worldwide)
    ibm_asia = OrgUnit("IBM_Asia", ibm_worldwide)
    ibm_china = OrgUnit("IBM_China", ibm_asia)
    print(ibm_worldwide)
    print(ibm_usa)
    print(ibm_asia)
    print(ibm_china)

I am sure this is a known paradigm, as it seems like a pretty common hierarchical class usage issue (a self referencing class). I know I could change the type of its_parent_org_unit to be object and it works, but this seems like the wrong thing to do, primarily since it scuppers my ability to check types in my calls. With its_parent_org_unit changed to be a type object I get the correct results:

IBM_Worldwide
IBM_Worldwide->IBM_USA
IBM_Worldwide->IBM_Asia
IBM_Worldwide->IBM_Asia->IBM_China

I am open to thoughts and suggestions. What is the most "pythonic" way to do this sort of thing?

PS: What is the name for this sort of "self referencing class" paradigm/problem, which I could use to look up other suggestions?

like image 964
R. G. Abbott Avatar asked Feb 25 '16 03:02

R. G. Abbott


People also ask

What are reasons for using type hinting?

Introduction to Type Hints As the code base gets larger, type hints can help to debug and prevent some dumb mistakes. If you're using an IDE like PyCharm, you'll get a warning message whenever you've used the wrong data type, provided you're using type hints.

Does Python type hinting improve performance?

Type hints improve IDEs and linters. They make it much easier to statically reason about your code. Type hints help you build and maintain a cleaner architecture. The act of writing type hints forces you to think about the types in your program.

How does type hinting work in Python?

Introduction to Python type hints It means that you need to declare types of variables, parameters, and return values of a function upfront. The predefined types allow the compilers to check the code before compiling and running the program.

Is type hinting enforced in Python?

Python will always remain a dynamically typed language. However, PEP 484 introduced type hints, which make it possible to also do static type checking of Python code. Unlike how types work in most other statically typed languages, type hints by themselves don't cause Python to enforce types.


1 Answers

Your problem is that you want to use type hints but you want this class itself to be able to take arguments of its own type.

The type hints PEP (0484) explains that you can use the string version of the type's name as a forward reference. The example there is of a Tree data structure which sounds remarkably similar to this OrgUnit one.

For example, this works:

class OrgUnit(object):

    def __init__(self,
                 an_org_name: str,
                 its_parent_org_unit: 'OrgUnit' = None
                 ):

In Python 3.7, you will be able to activate postponed evaluation of annotations with from __future__ import annotations. This will automatically store annotations as strings instead of evaluating them, so you can do

from __future__ import annotations

class OrgUnit(object):
    def __init__(self,
                 an_org_name: str,
                 its_parent_org_unit: OrgUnit= None
                 ):
        ...

This is scheduled to become the default in Python 4.0.

like image 145
Brian Cain Avatar answered Oct 07 '22 22:10

Brian Cain