Swift generic method should use overloaded generic function

Question

I'm having trouble getting the desired effect with Swift generics. I defined some generic functions, but for specific cases I would like to override them to provide additional features. When I call the functions from a non generic method/function everything works fine (it uses the specific versions when the argument types match and the generic version otherwise), but when I call the functions from a generic method/function it always uses the generic version of the function (never the specific versions).

Here's an example playground:

func printSomething <T> (something: T) {
    println("This is using the generic version.")
    println(something)
}

func printSomething(string: String) {
    println("This is using the specific version.")
    println(string)
}

func printSomeMoreThings <T> (something: T) {
    printSomething(something)
}

class TestClass <T> {

    var something: T

    init(something: T) {
        self.something = something
    }

    func printIt() {
        printSomething(self.something)
    }
}

printSomething("a")
println()
printSomeMoreThings("b")

let test = TestClass(something: "c")
println()
test.printIt()

This gives the following output:

This is using the specific version.
a

This is using the generic version.
b

This is using the generic version.
c

I would like it to use the specific version all the time (since it's calling printSomething with a String argument all the time). Is there a way to do this without overloading every method/function with a specific String version. Especially for the Class case, because I can't overload the class methods for specific types of T?

Answer 1

This currently cannot be achieved for reasons that you have mentioned yourself (you can't overload instance/class methods for specific types of <T>).

However, instead of using function overloading, you can check the type during runtime and act accordingly:

func printSomething<T>(something: T)
{
    if let somestring = something as? String
    {
        println("This is using the specific version.")
        println(somestring)

        return
    }

    println("This is using the generic version.")
    println(something)
}

The impact on performance should be negligible unless you call this function thousands of times.