My team is developing a new service oriented product with a web front-end. In discussions about what technologies we will use we have settled on running a JBoss application server, and Flex frontend (with possible desktop deployment using Adobe AIR), and web services to interface the client and server.
We've reached an impasse when it comes to which server technology to use for our business logic. The big argument is between EJB3 and Spring, with our biggest concerns being scalability and performance, and also maintainability of the code base.
Here are my questions:
The key difference between EJB and Spring is that EJB is a specification of Java EE while Spring is a framework or an implementation. Another key difference is that Spring does not support propagation of transaction context across remote calls while EJB does the same.
EJB is still there and growing up. There are many new features (SOAP/RESTful webservice, JPA entities, JAXB...) depend on it or at least reuse the philosophy of developing.
The Spring Framework is an application framework and IoC container for the Java platform. The framework was initially created as an alternative to EJB. Spring offers modular approach to adding new functionalities, which means that developers can use only parts they're interested in.
However, it is important to note that using Spring does not prevent you from using EJBs. In fact, Spring makes it much easier to access EJBs and implement EJBs and functionality within them.
There won't be much difference between EJB3 and Spring based on Performance. We chose Spring for the following reasons (not mentioned in the question):
The gap between EJB3 and Spring is much smaller than it was, clearly. That said, one of the downsides to EJB3 now is that you can only inject into a bean, so you can end up turning components into beans that don't need to be.
The argument about unit testing is fairly irrelevant now - EJB3 is clearly designed to be more easily unit testable.
The compatibility argument above is also kind of irrelevant: whether you use EJB3 or Spring, you're still reliant on 3rd party-provided implementations of transaction managers, JMS, etc.
What would swing it for me, however, is support by the community. Working on an EJB3 project last year, there just weren't a lot of people out there using it and talking about their problems. Spring, rightly or wrongly, is extremely pervasive, particularlty in the enterprise, and that makes it easier to find someone who's got the same problem you're trying to solve.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With