Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Ruby multiline block without do end

Tags:

ruby

I’m a beginner in Ruby, so I’m sorry to ask something so simple, but is there anything wrong with this code –

3.upto(9) {
  print "Hello"
  puts " World"
}

or

3.upto(9) { |n|
  print "Hello "
  puts n
}

It works well enough, but most of the code samples I see use the syntax of

3.upto(9) do |n|
  print "Hello "
  puts n
end

is it just the convention to only use curly braces for single statements? Coming from C/C# the first seems more natural to me, but when in Rome!

like image 451
Adam Rackis Avatar asked Sep 09 '10 19:09

Adam Rackis


2 Answers

There is a subtle difference between the two syntaxes. { } are higher precedence than do ... end. Thus, the following will pass bar and a block to method foo:

foo bar do ... end

while the following will pass a block to bar, and the result of that to foo:

foo bar { ... }

So your examples will act the same. However, if you left the parentheses off:

> 3.upto 9 { 
  puts "Hi" 
}
SyntaxError: compile error
(irb):82: syntax error, unexpected '{', expecting $end
3.upto 9 { 
          ^
    from (irb):82
    from :0

> 3.upto 9 do 
    puts "Hi" 
  end
Hi
Hi
Hi
Hi
Hi
Hi
Hi
=> 3

So, { } are more likely to catch you up if you leave off parentheses in Ruby, which is fairly common; for this reason, and because Ruby conditionals and other control constructs all use end as a delimiter, people usually use do ... end for multi-line code blocks that come at the end of a statement.

However, { } is frequently use in places where do ... end would be cumbersome, for instance, if you are chaining several methods together which take blocks. This can allow you to write short, one line little blocks which can be used as part of a method chain.

> [1,2,3].sort{|x,y| y<=>x}.map{|x| x+1}
=> [4, 3, 2]

Here's an example to illustrate this difference:

def foo arg
  if block_given?
    puts "Block given to foo"
    yield arg
  else
    puts "No block given to foo"
    arg
  end
end


def bar
  if block_given?
    puts "Block given to bar"
    yield "Yielded from bar"
  else
    puts "No block given to bar"
  end
  "Returned from bar"
end

irb(main):077:0> foo bar { |arg| puts arg }
Block given to bar
Yielded from bar
No block given to foo
=> "Returned from bar"
irb(main):078:0> foo bar do |arg| puts arg end
No block given to bar
Block given to foo
Returned from bar
=> nil
like image 106
Brian Campbell Avatar answered Nov 10 '22 01:11

Brian Campbell


It's just convention.

like image 28
sepp2k Avatar answered Nov 10 '22 00:11

sepp2k