Return id if a row exists, INSERT otherwise

Question

I'm writing a function in node.js to query a PostgreSQL table.
If the row exists, I want to return the id column from the row.
If it doesn't exist, I want to insert it and return the id (insert into ... returning id).

I've been trying variations of case and if else statements and can't seem to get it to work.

Answer 1

A solution in a single SQL statement. Requires PostgreSQL 8.4 or later though.
Consider the following demo:

Test setup:

CREATE TEMP TABLE tbl (
  id  serial PRIMARY KEY
 ,txt text   UNIQUE   -- obviously there is unique column (or set of columns)
);

INSERT INTO tbl(txt) VALUES ('one'), ('two');

INSERT / SELECT command:

WITH v AS (SELECT 'three'::text AS txt)
    ,s AS (SELECT id FROM tbl JOIN v USING (txt))
    ,i AS (
       INSERT INTO tbl (txt)
       SELECT txt
       FROM   v
       WHERE  NOT EXISTS (SELECT * FROM s)
       RETURNING id
       )
SELECT id, 'i'::text AS src FROM i
UNION  ALL
SELECT id, 's' FROM s;

• The first CTE v is not strictly necessary, but achieves that you have to enter your values only once.

• The second CTE s selects the id from tbl if the "row" exists.

• The third CTE i inserts the "row" into tbl if (and only if) it does not exist, returning id.

• The final SELECT returns the id. I added a column src indicating the "source" - whether the "row" pre-existed and id comes from a SELECT, or the "row" was new and so is the id.

• This version should be as fast as possible as it does not need an additional SELECT from tbl and uses the CTEs instead.

To make this safe against possible race conditions in a multi-user environment:
Also for updated techniques using the new UPSERT in Postgres 9.5 or later:

• Is SELECT or INSERT in a function prone to race conditions?

Answer 2

I would suggest doing the checking on the database side and just returning the id to nodejs.

Example:

CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION foo(p_param1 tableFoo.attr1%TYPE, p_param2 tableFoo.attr1%TYPE) RETURNS tableFoo.id%TYPE AS $$
  DECLARE
  v_id tableFoo.pk%TYPE;
  BEGIN
    SELECT id
    INTO v_id
    FROM tableFoo
    WHERE attr1 = p_param1
    AND attr2 = p_param2;

    IF v_id IS NULL THEN
      INSERT INTO tableFoo(id, attr1, attr2) VALUES (DEFAULT, p_param1, p_param2)
      RETURNING id INTO v_id;
    END IF;

    RETURN v_id:

  END;
$$ LANGUAGE plpgsql;

And than on the Node.js-side (i'm using node-postgres in this example):

var pg = require('pg');
pg.connect('someConnectionString', function(connErr, client){

  //do some errorchecking here

  client.query('SELECT id FROM foo($1, $2);', ['foo', 'bar'], function(queryErr, result){

    //errorchecking

    var id = result.rows[0].id;      

  };

});

Answer 3

Something like this, if you are on PostgreSQL 9.1

with test_insert as (
   insert into foo (id, col1, col2)
   select 42, 'Foo', 'Bar'
   where not exists (select * from foo where id = 42)
   returning foo.id, foo.col1, foo.col2
)
select id, col1, col2
from test_insert
union 
select id, col1, col2
from foo
where id = 42;

It's a bit longish and you need to repeat the id to test for several times, but I can't think of a different solution that involves a single SQL statement.

If a row with id=42 exists, the writeable CTE will not insert anything and thus the existing row will be returned by the second union part.

When testing this I actually thought the new row would be returned twice (therefor a union not a union all) but it turns out that the result of the second select statement is actually evaluated before the whole statement is run and it does not see the newly inserted row. So in case a new row is inserted, it will be taken from the "returning" part.