Performance between String.format and StringBuilder

Question

To concatenate String we often use StringBuilder instead of String + String, but also we can do the same with String.format which returns the formatted string by given locale, format and arguments.

Examples:

Concatenate the string with StringBuilder

String concatenateStringWithStringBuilder(String name, String lName, String nick) {     final StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder("Contact {");     sb.append(", name='").append(name)       .append(", lastName='").append(lName)       .append(", nickName='").append(nick)       .append('}');     return sb.toString(); } 

Concatenate the string with StringFormat:

String concatenateStringWithStringFormat(String name, String lName, String nick) {     return String.format("Contact {name=%s, lastName=%s, nickName=%s}", name, lName, nick); } 

In performance, is String.Format as efficient as StringBuilder? Which one is better to concatenate strings and why?

UPDATE

I checked the similar question, but doesn´t answer my question. So far I have used StringBuilder to concatenate strings, should I follow it using? Or should I use String.format? the question is which one is better and why?

Answer 1

What is "better" solely depends on your requirements:

• For instance String Builder will be faster, but the code will be much more unreadable, and and it would be easier to make a mistake.

• On the other hand String.format() produces more readable code at the cost of performance.

JMH benchmark to illustrate the performance difference (notice that the string builder code is longer and very hard to understand how the resulting string would look like):

@Fork(1) @State(Scope.Benchmark) @OutputTimeUnit(TimeUnit.MILLISECONDS) @Measurement(iterations = 10) @Warmup(iterations = 10) @BenchmarkMode(Mode.Throughput) public class StringFormatBenchmark {     private String name = "UserName";     private String lName = "LUserName";     private String nick = "UserNick";      @Benchmark     public void stringFormat(Blackhole blackhole) {         final String result = String.format("Contact {name=%s, lastName=%s, nickName=%s}", name, lName, nick);         blackhole.consume(result);     }      @Benchmark     public void stringBuilder(Blackhole blackhole) {         final StringBuffer sb = new StringBuffer("Contact {");         sb.append(", name='").append(name)                 .append(", lastName='").append(lName)                 .append(", nickName='").append(nick)                 .append('}');         final String result = sb.toString();         blackhole.consume(result);     } } 

And the results:

Benchmark                             Mode  Cnt      Score     Error   Units StringFormatBenchmark.stringBuilder  thrpt   10  10617.210 ± 157.302  ops/ms StringFormatBenchmark.stringFormat   thrpt   10    960.658 ±   7.398  ops/ms 

For non performance critical code I prefer using the String.format(), because it's easier and more pleasant to use. Also it's visible what the resulting string would look like, by simply looking at the pattern. If I'm doing a performance critical code, or something that has to have a low GC impact, I would use a StringBuilder because it's faster and can be reused.