Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Pandas transform() vs apply()

I don't understand why apply and transform return different dtypes when called on the same data frame. The way I explained the two functions to myself before went something along the lines of "apply collapses the data, and transform does exactly the same thing as apply but preserves the original index and doesn't collapse." Consider the following.

df = pd.DataFrame({'id': [1,1,1,2,2,2,2,3,3,4],
                   'cat': [1,1,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,1]})

Let's identify those ids which have a nonzero entry in the cat column.

>>> df.groupby('id')['cat'].apply(lambda x: (x == 1).any())
id
1     True
2     True
3    False
4     True
Name: cat, dtype: bool

Great. If we wanted to create an indicator column, however, we could do the following.

>>> df.groupby('id')['cat'].transform(lambda x: (x == 1).any())
0    1
1    1
2    1
3    1
4    1
5    1
6    1
7    0
8    0
9    1
Name: cat, dtype: int64

I don't understand why the dtype is now int64 instead of the boolean returned by the any() function.

When I change the original data frame to contain some booleans (note that the zeros remain), the transform approach returns booleans in an object column. This is an extra mystery to me since all of the values are boolean, but it's listed as object apparently to match the dtype of the original mixed-type column of integers and booleans.

df = pd.DataFrame({'id': [1,1,1,2,2,2,2,3,3,4],
                   'cat': [True,True,0,0,True,0,0,0,0,True]})

>>> df.groupby('id')['cat'].transform(lambda x: (x == 1).any())
0     True
1     True
2     True
3     True
4     True
5     True
6     True
7    False
8    False
9     True
Name: cat, dtype: object

However, when I use all booleans, the transform function returns a boolean column.

df = pd.DataFrame({'id': [1,1,1,2,2,2,2,3,3,4],
                   'cat': [True,True,False,False,True,False,False,False,False,True]})

>>> df.groupby('id')['cat'].transform(lambda x: (x == 1).any())
0     True
1     True
2     True
3     True
4     True
5     True
6     True
7    False
8    False
9     True
Name: cat, dtype: bool

Using my acute pattern-recognition skills, it appears that the dtype of the resulting column mirrors that of the original column. I would appreciate any hints about why this occurs or what's going on under the hood in the transform function. Cheers.

like image 846
3novak Avatar asked Jan 05 '17 02:01

3novak


1 Answers

It looks like SeriesGroupBy.transform() tries to cast the result dtype to the same one as the original column has, but DataFrameGroupBy.transform() doesn't seem to do that:

In [139]: df.groupby('id')['cat'].transform(lambda x: (x == 1).any())
Out[139]:
0    1
1    1
2    1
3    1
4    1
5    1
6    1
7    0
8    0
9    1
Name: cat, dtype: int64

#                         v       v
In [140]: df.groupby('id')[['cat']].transform(lambda x: (x == 1).any())
Out[140]:
     cat
0   True
1   True
2   True
3   True
4   True
5   True
6   True
7  False
8  False
9   True

In [141]: df.dtypes
Out[141]:
cat    int64
id     int64
dtype: object
like image 136
MaxU - stop WAR against UA Avatar answered Oct 20 '22 23:10

MaxU - stop WAR against UA