Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

.NET LINQ query syntax vs method chain

Is there any performance difference between the following two statements?

from item in collection  where item.id == 3 select item 

and

collection.Where(item => item.id ==3) 

In general, is there any performance difference between the LINQ syntax and the method chain?

like image 824
Radu D Avatar asked Sep 23 '10 08:09

Radu D


People also ask

What is the difference between query syntax and method syntax in LINQ?

Query syntax and method syntax are semantically identical, but many people find query syntax simpler and easier to read. Some queries must be expressed as method calls. For example, you must use a method call to express a query that retrieves the number of elements that match a specified condition.

What is query syntax in LINQ?

LINQ query syntax is consist of a set of query keywords defined into the . NET Framework version 3.5 or Higher. This allows the programmer or developers to write the commands similar to SQL style in the code(C# or VB.NET) without using quotes. It is also know as the Query Expression Syntax.

What are the different LINQ query methods?

There are the following two ways to write LINQ queries using the Standard Query operators, in other words Select, From, Where, Orderby, Join, Groupby and many more. Using lambda expressions. Using SQL like query expressions.

How many types of LINQ query are there?

LINQ queries can be written in two syntax types, a Query Syntax and a Method Syntax.


1 Answers

No, because they are compiled into exactly the same code.

Basically query expressions are "pre-processed" by the compiler into "C# 3 without query expressions" and then the rules of overloading, lambda expression translation etc are applied as normal. It's a really elegant system which means that the rules for query expressions are limited to just one small bit of the spec.

Of course, there are various things you can write in "chained method" syntax which can't be written in query expression syntax, either due to using other overloads or the methods simply not being supported (e.g. Count()) - but unless you're using those, the compiled code will be exactly the same. Pick the most readable alternative for any particular scenario.

like image 191
Jon Skeet Avatar answered Sep 21 '22 02:09

Jon Skeet