Model View Controller: Does the Controller or Model fetch data off the server?

Question

For example: Let's say I'm grabbing a list of names and saving it to an NSMutableArray. Do I implement the method of actually calling the server to fetch the data in the controller (UIViewController) or the model(Friends object)?

Answer 1

It's a design decision that depends on what you're trying to accomplish. If your model only makes sense in the context of a single service, or if you want your model to provide access to all the data on the server, then build the connection to the server into your data model. This might make sense if you are, for example, building a client for a service like Twitter or Flickr.

On the other hand, if you're just grabbing a file from a server and that's the end of it, it may make sense to do the communication in the controller. Controllers tend to be less reusable and more customized for the particular behavior of the application. Keeping the specifics about where the data comes from out of the model makes the model more reusable. It also makes it easy to test -- you can write test code that just reads a local file and stores the data in the model.