Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

LINQ extension methods - Any() vs. Where() vs. Exists()

Tags:

c#

linq

Unfortunately the names of these methods make terrible search terms, and I've been unable to find a good resource that explains the difference between these methods--as in when to use each.

Thanks.

Edit:

The sort of query that I'm trying to fully understand is something like this:

context.Authors.Where(a => a.Books.Any(b => b.BookID == bookID)).ToList(); 

And thanks to all who've answered.

like image 519
asfsadf Avatar asked Sep 13 '10 18:09

asfsadf


People also ask

What is any () in LINQ?

The Any operator is used to check whether any element in the sequence or collection satisfy the given condition. If one or more element satisfies the given condition, then it will return true. If any element does not satisfy the given condition, then it will return false.

What are LINQ extension methods?

Linq provides standard query operators like filtering, sorting, grouping, aggregation, and concatenations, and it has many operators to achive many types of functionalities, which are called extension methods, in LINQ.

What is the difference between first () and single () extension methods in LINQ?

1. First() returns the first element of a sequence even there is a single element in that sequence. 2. Single() returns the single element of a sequence and that element should be the exactly a single one.

Where any vs any?

The Any() with the predicate can perform its task without an iterator ( yield return ). Using a Where() creates an iterator, which adds has a performance impact (albeit very small).


2 Answers

Where returns a new sequence of items matching the predicate.

Any returns a Boolean value; there's a version with a predicate (in which case it returns whether or not any items match) and a version without (in which case it returns whether the query-so-far contains any items).

I'm not sure about Exists - it's not a LINQ standard query operator. If there's a version for the Entity Framework, perhaps it checks for existence based on a key - a sort of specialized form of Any? (There's an Exists method in List<T> which is similar to Any(predicate) but that predates LINQ.)

like image 99
Jon Skeet Avatar answered Sep 24 '22 17:09

Jon Skeet


context.Authors.Where(a => a.Books.Any(b => b.BookID == bookID)).ToList();

a.Books is the list of books by that author. The property is automatically created by Linq-to-Sql, provided you have a foreign-key relationship set up.

So, a.Books.Any(b => b.BookID == bookID) translates to "Do any of the books by this author have an ID of bookID", which makes the complete expression "Who are the authors of the book with id bookID?"

That could also be written something like

  from a in context.Authors   join b in context.Books on a.AuthorId equal b.AuthorID   where b.BookID == bookID   select a; 

UPDATE: Any() as far as I know, only returns a bool. Its effective implementation is:

 public Any(this IEnumerable<T> coll, Func<T, bool> predicate)  {      foreach(T t in coll)      {          if (predicte(t))             return true;      }      return false;  } 
like image 40
James Curran Avatar answered Sep 23 '22 17:09

James Curran