Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

linker tells me it can't resolve symbols, but they're there?

I am trying to compile a simple test app using a library I've written. This compiles and runs fine on other machines.

I have libroller.so available at /usr/lib. I'm compiling a main.cpp as such:

g++ -g3 -Wall -I"../../" -lrt -lroller -o rap main.o

It complains of numerous errors such as:

/....../main.cpp:51: undefined reference to `Log::i(char const*, ...)'

However, I know that these exist in this so:

nm -Ca /usr/lib/libroller.so | grep "Log::i"            
00000000001f5d50 T Log::i(char const*, ...)
0000000000149530 W Log::i(std::string const&)

Both are 64 bit:

file /usr/lib/libroller.so           
/usr/lib/libroller.so: ELF 64-bit LSB shared object, x86-64, version 1 (SYSV), dynamically linked, not stripped

file main.o   
main.o: ELF 64-bit LSB relocatable, x86-64, version 1 (SYSV), not stripped

Unlike GCC and ld can't find exported symbols...but they're there! I'm pretty sure these symbols are defined. The same .so works with another using some of the same symbols.

EDIT/ANSWER: The order of objects is important. Placing main.o before the libraries was necessary. I'm guessing the linker had no unresolved symbols to deal with until it got to main.o -- which was the last object in its list. I'm still a little confused as to why this worked on other machines for many months...

like image 339
notlesh Avatar asked Dec 05 '11 07:12

notlesh


People also ask

How do linkers resolve symbols?

The linker resolves symbol references by associating each reference with exactly one symbol definition from the symbol tables of its input relocatable object files. Symbol resolution is straightforward for references to local symbols that are defined in the same module as the reference.

How to resolve linker errors?

You can fix the errors by including the source code file that contains the definitions as part of the compilation. Alternatively, you can pass . obj files or . lib files that contain the definitions to the linker.

What is Cannot resolve symbol in Android Studio?

Most often “R cannot be resolved” error appears if there is an issue with some of your resource files. Due to this error, you are unable to build your application. That's why we need to solve this error as it not getting away by just doing a simple restart or hitting Alt+Enter.


2 Answers

Change:

g++ -g3 -Wall -I"../../" -lrt -lroller -o rap main.o

to:

g++ -g3 -Wall main.o -lroller -lrt -o rap 

Link order matters (and the -I is redundant in this instance).

like image 84
Paul R Avatar answered Sep 28 '22 01:09

Paul R


Consider changing the sequence of library and main.o:

g++ -g3 -Wall -I"../../" -o rap main.o -lrt -lroller

Have a look at this post: Why does the order in which libraries are linked sometimes cause errors in GCC?

like image 33
Lei Mou Avatar answered Sep 28 '22 00:09

Lei Mou