Java File Locking

Question

I have several threads (some of which are spawned by Process X, others by Process Y, et cetera), and each thread needs to write to a file MyFile. However, if Thread T1 starts writing to MyFile first, then, when Thread T2 starts writing, it needs to wait for T1 to release the file, so that it can read the contents that were written in Thread T1. In other words, each thread would have a finalizeThread method, like so:

private void finalizeThread() {
    File f = new File("MyFile.dat");
    f.createNewFile();  // atomically creates the file, if it doesn't exist
    locked_section {
        readContentsFromFile(f); // read contents if some other thread already modified the file
        modifyContentsFromFile(f); // modify
        writeFile(f); // write, so that new threads can see the content modified by this thread
    }
}

My question is: How can I accomplish the locked_section in the above code? I was looking into the FileLock class, but it says in the Javadoc that "File locks are held on behalf of the entire Java virtual machine. They are not suitable for controlling access to a file by multiple threads within the same virtual machine.".

Answer 1

If the file is only accessed from your program, the synchronized lock object is okay. But if you want to protect the file from being changed by other programs while you're working on it, you can use Java's file locking features in java.nio.channels.FileLock (example). As the text says, mind that on some operating systems, programs can still change files if they don't check for an existing file lock.

Answer 2

Instead of sharing a lock, maybe you could have a separate process that was responsible for maintaining a lock on the file. To begin your read/modify/write step, a Thread would have to ask this central process for the lock via HTTP, or messaging, or whatever you like. If the request is denied, the Thread would go to sleep, wake up, and try again. Otherwise the Thread would read/modify/write and then tell the locking process that it is releasing the lock.