Java: accessing protected fields from inner class

Question

Recently I've faced a problem getting a runtime error java.lang.IllegalAccessError when trying to access from inner class a protected field declared in outer's parent class that was loaded by a different class loader. Briefly:

1. Class Parent has protected field p.
2. Class Outer extends Parent.
3. Class Inner is an inner class defined in class Outer.
4. Inside Inner class there's a code: Outer.this.p.
5. All classes are declared in the same package.

Normally it's compiled and runs fine until Parent and Outer class are loaded by different class loaders. In this case we get java.lang.IllegalAccessError when trying to access Outer.this.p from Inner. I found an old bug report (which appeared to be a feature) describing this behavior:

https://bugs.java.com/bugdatabase/view_bug.do?bug_id=6258289

But resolution sounds contradictive to me:

The key is that in the failing case the inner class isn't in the same package (and isn't a subclass of) ConcreteCommand/AbstractCommand. This is simply a violation of the Java specification for protected classes.

It sounds correct. But if we declare Parent and Outer classes in different packages but load with the single class loader (simply create sample console app without any jar loadings) we don't get any errors. So technically it's a violation of Java spec for protected classes but since we use an inner class it works.

So we have different behavior for two cases of "different packages".

1. Declared in different packages, loaded by single class loader - OK.
2. Declared in single package, loaded by different class loaders - NOT OK.

Could someone give a clear explanation of how inner class gets access to parent's fields and why it works differently for two cases?

Answer 1

• Same class loader it seems to be working
• Did I get the question right?
• Do you have any unit test case to reproduce your issue?

Parent Class

package p1;

public class Parent {
    
    protected String p = "Value from Parent";
    
    public void test() {
        System.out.println(p);
    }

}

Outer Class

package p1;

public class Outer extends Parent {

    class Inner {
        public void test() {
            Outer.this.p = "Value set from Inner";
            System.out.println(Outer.this.p);
        }
    }

    public void test() {
        new Inner().test();
    }
}

Main Class

package p1;

public class Main {

    public static void main(String[] args) {
        Parent p = new Parent();
        p.test();
        p = new Outer();
        p.test();
    }
}

Output

Value from Parent
Value set from Inner