Is this the proper method to Long Polling(Comet programming)

Question

First I would like to appreciate all of you great people for being so helpful to new programmers.

I have a question about long polling. I have studied some articles about Long polling technique of Comet Programming. The method seems a lot difficult to me because it also sometimes requires installing some scripts on the server side.

Now I have found an example on long polling. Its working great but I am not sure if it is the proper method. The example script is about a chat-like application. This php script works as follows:

1. The php script checks the data.txt file continuously until it is changed.
2. As soon as the data.txt is changed, the new text is outputted on the webpage.

Here is the php script:

<?php
$filename  = dirname(__FILE__).'/data.txt';

// store new message in the file
$msg = isset($_GET['msg']) ? $_GET['msg'] : '';
if ($msg != '')
{
    file_put_contents($filename,$msg);
    die();
}

// infinite loop until the data file is not modified
$lastmodif    = isset($_GET['timestamp']) ? $_GET['timestamp'] : 0;
$currentmodif = filemtime($filename);
while ($currentmodif <= $lastmodif) // check if the data file has been modified
{
    usleep(500000); // sleep 500ms to unload the CPU
    clearstatcache();
    $currentmodif = filemtime($filename);
}

// return a json array
$response = array();
$response['msg']       = file_get_contents($filename);
$response['timestamp'] = $currentmodif;
echo json_encode($response);
flush();
?>

I am not including the webpage code to keep the question simple. The webpage has just a div which shows the text of data.txt whenever it is changed.

Main points of my question are:

• Is this looping method the proper method to long poll the server?
• Also when the server is executing sleep(); what will happen to other simultaneous requests?
• Is there any technique to reduce the load on server due to long polling's continuous script?
• If a client starting this long poll request disconnects, how can we know and stop the script for that disconnected client accordingly?

Kindly guide me with this problem... Thanks

Answer 1

Yes, that's an idea. You should keep in mind though that this script will not end, and an instance of PHP will be spawned for every user. I'm using the longpoll logic with v8cgi server side. After the client started an XMLHttp Request (XHR), the server starts checking with intervals for new input. I have added a timer server side, to send a response every 5 minutes, after which the client - if not disconnected - resends the XHR and the procedure repeats.

So every instance of the server side mechanism runs no longer than 5 minutes max because if the client is disconnected, the response the server sends after 5 minutes isn't followed by a new XHR.

The process looks like this:

• client sends XHR
• server spawns process an checks periodically for updates
• if some update has to be send: server sends response
  • client processes response and restarts XHR
  • server spawns process and checks periodically for updates
• if 5 minutes passed without updates:
  • server sends response and exits spawned process
  • client processes (empty) response an restarts XHR
  • server spawns new process and starts checking
• if some update has to be send: server sends response
• [...]
• if 5 minutes passed without updates:
• [...]
• until client is disconnected (= no new XHR after server response)

Answer 2

yes this is an easy and handy way to do that and it is not the proper method, but not the best idea. because it suffers and will cause many problem as the users will get increased.

and for shared hosting this is not a good idea to do that, this method will work fine only when the users are not huge amount, and if you have your own server. if you would use this method in shared hosting server then you may face maximum server resource used, or session locking problems and the http service might be unavailable for some time.

or you can use existing api, for chat applications, or have a dedicated server that can run the scripts like node.js and similar server modules