Is there a more efficient way to replace NULL with NA in a list?

Question

I quite often come across data that is structured something like this:

employees <- list(     list(id = 1,              dept = "IT",              age = 29,              sportsteam = "softball"),     list(id = 2,              dept = "IT",              age = 30,              sportsteam = NULL),     list(id = 3,              dept = "IT",              age = 29,              sportsteam = "hockey"),     list(id = 4,              dept = NULL,              age = 29,              sportsteam = "softball")) 

In many cases such lists could be tens of millions of items long, so memory concerns and efficiency are always a concern.

I would like to turn the list into a dataframe but if I run:

library(data.table) employee.df <- rbindlist(employees) 

I get errors because of the NULL values. My normal strategy is to use a function like:

nullToNA <- function(x) {     x[sapply(x, is.null)] <- NA     return(x) } 

and then:

employees <- lapply(employees, nullToNA) employee.df <- rbindlist(employees) 

which returns

   id dept age sportsteam 1:  1   IT  29   softball 2:  2   IT  30         NA 3:  3   IT  29     hockey 4:  4   NA  29   softball 

However, the nullToNA function is very slow when applied to 10 million cases so it'd be good if there was a more efficient approach.

One point that seems to slow the process down it the is.null function can only be applied to one item at a time (unlike is.na which can scan a full list in one go).

Any advice on how to do this operation efficiently on a large dataset?

Answer 1

Many efficiency problems in R are solved by first changing the original data into a form that makes the processes that follow as fast and easy as possible. Usually, this is matrix form.

If you bring all the data together with rbind, your nullToNA function no longer has to search though nested lists, and therefore sapply serves its purpose (looking though a matrix) more efficiently. In theory, this should make the process faster.

Good question, by the way.

> dat <- do.call(rbind, lapply(employees, rbind)) > dat      id dept age sportsteam [1,] 1  "IT" 29  "softball" [2,] 2  "IT" 30  NULL       [3,] 3  "IT" 29  "hockey"   [4,] 4  NULL 29  "softball"  > nullToNA(dat)      id dept age sportsteam [1,] 1  "IT" 29  "softball" [2,] 2  "IT" 30  NA         [3,] 3  "IT" 29  "hockey"   [4,] 4  NA   29  "softball"