I am trying to integrate over a constant function in MATLAB 2017a, but I am stuck. First of all when I integrate using the following script, I get the right output. So the script works for a x0
which depends on t
.
function E=sol(n,k)
x0 = @(t) t^(2);
j = 0;
E = zeros(n,1);
while j < n+1 ;
K = matlabFunction(subs(po(j,k))) ;
eval(sprintf('x%d = integral(K,0,1);',j+1)) ;
E(j+1,1) = subs(sprintf('x%d',j+1))
j = j+1;
end
end
Where function po(j,k)
is as follows,
function A_j = po(j,k) % Adomian polynomials
if j >0
x = sym('x',[1 j]);
syms p; % Assinging a symbolic variable for p
syms x0;
S = x0+ sum(p.^(1:j) .* x) ; % Sum of p*x up to order j
Q =f(S,k); % Taking the k-th power of S, i.e.
A_nc = diff(Q,p,j)/factorial(j); % Taking the j-th order derivative
A_j = subs(A_nc,p,0) ; % Filling in p=0
else
syms x0;
S = x0;
A_j =f(S,k); % Taking the k-th power of S,
end
end
And where f(x,k)
is,
function F = f(x,k) % Nonlinear function of k power
F = x^k ;
end
Now when I cal sol(n,k)
it does work. But when I try to change my x0
function in sol(n,k)
in a constant function like,
function E=solcon(n,k)
x0 = @(t) 2.*ones(size(t));
j = 0;
E = zeros(n,1);
while j < n+1 ;
K = matlabFunction(subs(po(j,k))) ;
eval(sprintf('x%d = integral(K,0,1);',j+1)) ;
E(j+1,1) = subs(sprintf('x%d',j+1))
j = j+1;
end
end
It does not work, As you can see I added *ones(size(t));
just to make it a function of t
. But unfortunately it still doesn't work when I call,
K = matlabFunction(subs(po(j,k))) ;
I get,
@()4.0
And then I get an error when I call,
eval(sprintf('x%d = integral(K,0,1);',j+1))
Could anyone help me out trying to integrate over a constant?
The error I get when I call solcon(10,2)
is
Error using symengine>@()4.0
Too many input arguments.
Error in integralCalc/iterateScalarValued (line 314)
fx = FUN(t);
Error in integralCalc/vadapt (line 132)
[q,errbnd] = iterateScalarValued(u,tinterval,pathlen);
Error in integralCalc (line 75)
[q,errbnd] = vadapt(@AtoBInvTransform,interval);
Error in integral (line 88)
Q = integralCalc(fun,a,b,opstruct);
Error in solcon1 (line 7)
eval(sprintf('x%d = integral(K,0,1);',j+1)) ;
EDIT 2 I used the following script,
function E=solcon(n,k)
x0 = @(t) 2.*ones(size(t));
j = 0;
E = zeros(n,1);
while j < n+1 ;
K = matlabFunction(subs(po(j,k))) ;
fstr= func2str(K)
if fstr(3) == ')';
x{j+1} = K*(1-0)
else x{j+1} = integral(K,0,1)
end
E(j+1,1) = subs(x{j+1},1);
j = j+1
end
end
But the following error occurs,
Undefined operator '*' for input arguments of type 'function_handle'.
Error in solcone1 (line 9)
x{j+1} = K*(1-0);
I am going to ignore the terrible choice of using eval
, especially when you can do
x{j+1} = integral(K,0,1);
Read more on why dynamic variables and eval are terrible
Your problem is that matlabFunction
is a smartass. When it detects that your function does not have any dependency to x
, it gives you a function with empty input arguments @()4.0
. As you see, integral
does not like that.
A way of solving the problem is detecting this before calling integral
. You could check if it has input arguments, and if it does not, then evaluate the integral "by hand"
...
while j < n+1 ;
K = matlabFunction(subs(po(j,k))) ;
fstr=func2str(K);
if fstr(3)==')'
x{j+1}=K()*(1-0); % evaluate the integral yourself
else
x{j+1} = integral(K,0,1);
end
E(j+1,1) = subs(x{j+1});
j = j+1;
end
...
The problem is considerably more difficult that I though I was. Either rewrite the entire thing, or using eval:
...
while j < n+1 ;
K = matlabFunction(subs(po(j,k))) ;
fstr=func2str(K);
if j==0
eval(sprintf('x%d = K()*(1-0);;',j+1)) ;
else
eval(sprintf('x%d = integral(K,0,1);',j+1)) ;
end
E(j+1,1) = subs(sprintf('x%d',j+1));
j = j+1;
end
...
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With