How to undefine a variable in Scheme?

Question

How to undefine a variable in Scheme? Is this possible?

Answer 1

You're touching a nerve here. Scheme doesn't have a very clear standard notion of how top-level environments work. Why? Because the Scheme standards represent a compromise between two sets of people with very different ideas of how Scheme should work:

• The interpretive crowd, who sees the top-level environment as you describe above: a runtime hash-table where bindings are progressively added as program interpretation proceeds.
• Then there's the compilation crowd, who sees the top-level environment as something that must be fully computable at compilation time (i.e., a compiler must be able to conclusively identify all of the names that will be bound in the top-level environment).

Your "how do I undefine a variable" question only makes sense in the first model.

Note that the interpretive model, where a program's top-level bindings depend on what code paths get taken, makes efficient compilation of Scheme code much harder for many reasons. For example, how can a Scheme compiler inline a procedure invocation if the name of the procedure is a top-level binding that may not just change during runtime, but even disappear into nothingness?

I'm firmly in the compilation camp here, so what I would recommend to you is to avoid writing code that relies on the ability to add or remove top-level bindings at runtime, or even that requires the use of top-level variables (though those are often unavoidable). Some Scheme systems (e.g., Racket) are able to produce reasonably good compiled code, but if you make those assumptions you'll trip them up in that regard.