How to keep React component state between mount/unmount?

Question

I have a simple component <StatefulView> that maintains an internal state. I have another component <App> that toggles whether or not <StatefulView> is rendered.

However, I want to keep <StatefulView>'s internal state between mounting/unmouting.

I figured I could instantiate the component in <App> and then control whether its rendered/mounted.

var StatefulView = React.createClass({   getInitialState: function() {     return {       count: 0     }   },   inc: function() {     this.setState({count: this.state.count+1})   },   render: function() {     return (         <div>           <button onClick={this.inc}>inc</button>           <div>count:{this.state.count}</div>         </div>     )   } });  var App = React.createClass({   getInitialState: function() {     return {       show: true,       component: <StatefulView/>     }   },   toggle: function() {     this.setState({show: !this.state.show})   },   render: function() {     var content = this.state.show ? this.state.component : false     return (       <div>         <button onClick={this.toggle}>toggle</button>         {content}       </div>     )   } }); 

This apparently doesnt work and a new <StatefulView> is created on each toggle.

Here's a JSFiddle.

Is there a way to hang on to the same component after it is unmounted so it can be re-mounted?

Answer 1

Since you can't keep the state in the component itself when it unmounts, you have to decide where else it should be saved.

These are your options:

1. React state in parent: If a parent component remains mounted, maybe it should be the owner of the state or could provide an initial state to an uncontrolled component below. You can pass the value back up before the component unmounts. With React context you can hoist the state to the very top of your app (see e.g. unstated).
2. Outside of React: E.g. use-local-storage-state. Note that you might need to manually reset the state inbetween tests. Other options are query params in the URL, state management libraries like MobX or Redux, etc.

I've you're looking for an easy solution where the data is persisted outside of React, this Hook might come in handy:

const memoryState = {};  function useMemoryState(key, initialState) {   const [state, setState] = useState(() => {     const hasMemoryValue = Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(memoryState, key);     if (hasMemoryValue) {       return memoryState[key]     } else {       return typeof initialState === 'function' ? initialState() : initialState;     }   });    function onChange(nextState) {     memoryState[key] = nextState;     setState(nextState);   }    return [state, onChange]; } 

Usage:

const [todos, setTodos] = useMemoryState('todos', ['Buy milk']); 

Answer 2

OK. So after talking with a bunch of people, it turns out that there is no way to save an instance of a component. Thus, we HAVE to save it elsewhere.

1) The most obvious place to save the state is within the parent component.

This isn't an option for me because I'm trying to push and pop views from a UINavigationController-like object.

2) You can save the state elsewhere, like a Flux store, or in some global object.

This also isn't the best option for me because it would be a nightmare keeping track of which data belongs to which view in which Navigation controller, etc.

3) Pass a mutable object to save and restore the state from.

This was a suggestion I found while commenting in various issue tickets on React's Github repo. This seems to be the way to go for me because I can create a mutable object and pass it as props, then re-render the same object with the same mutable prop.

I've actually modified it a little to be more generalized and I'm using functions instead of mutable objects. I think this is more sane -- immutable data is always preferable to me. Here's what I'm doing:

function createInstance() {   var func = null;   return {     save: function(f) {       func = f;     },     restore: function(context) {       func && func(context);     }   } } 

Now in getInitialState I'm creating a new instance for the component:

component: <StatefulView instance={createInstance()}/> 

Then in the StatefulView I just need to save and restore in componentWillMount and componentWillUnmount.

componentWillMount: function() {   this.props.instance.restore(this) }, componentWillUnmount: function() {   var state = this.state   this.props.instance.save(function(ctx){     ctx.setState(state)   }) } 

And that's it. It works really well for me. Now I can treat the components as if they're instances :)