Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

How to create the int 1 at two different memory locations?

Tags:

python

cpython

I want to show someone how using is instead of == to compare integers can fail. I thought this would work, but it didn't:

>>> import copy
>>> x = 1
>>> y = copy.deepcopy(x)
>>> x is y
True

I can do this easily for bigger integers:

>>> x = 500
>>> y = 500
>>> x is y
False

How can I demonstrate the same thing with smaller integers which might typically be used for enum-like purposes in python?

like image 731
wim Avatar asked Jan 11 '23 07:01

wim


1 Answers

The following example fails in both Python 2 and 3:

>>> n=12345
>>> ((n**8)+1) % (n**4) is 1
False
>>> ((n**8)+1) % (n**4) == 1
True

The reasons are slightly different. Python 2 uses the int type for small integers and the long type for arbitrary precision values. Only the int type is interned so the example fails when a 1L is returned.

Python 3 only uses the arbitrary precision type (and renamed it to int). The example fails because the remainder calculation internally computes a value of 1 and returns it. The interning check is only done when objects are created and the object was created at the start of the calculation before it had the value 1.

like image 159
casevh Avatar answered Feb 18 '23 21:02

casevh