How to convert comma separated values to rows in oracle?

Question

Here is the DDL --

create table tbl1 (
   id number,
   value varchar2(50)
);

insert into tbl1 values (1, 'AA, UT, BT, SK, SX');
insert into tbl1 values (2, 'AA, UT, SX');
insert into tbl1 values (3, 'UT, SK, SX, ZF');

Notice, here value is comma separated string.

But, we need result like following-

ID VALUE
-------------
1  AA
1  UT
1  BT
1  SK
1  SX
2  AA
2  UT
2  SX
3  UT
3  SK
3  SX
3  ZF

How do we write SQL for this?

Answer 1

I agree that this is a really bad design. Try this if you can't change that design:

select distinct id, trim(regexp_substr(value,'[^,]+', 1, level) ) value, level
  from tbl1
   connect by regexp_substr(value, '[^,]+', 1, level) is not null
   order by id, level;

OUPUT

id value level
1   AA  1
1   UT  2
1   BT  3
1   SK  4
1   SX  5
2   AA  1
2   UT  2
2   SX  3
3   UT  1
3   SK  2
3   SX  3
3   ZF  4

Credits to this

To remove duplicates in a more elegant and efficient way (credits to @mathguy)

select id, trim(regexp_substr(value,'[^,]+', 1, level) ) value, level
  from tbl1
   connect by regexp_substr(value, '[^,]+', 1, level) is not null
      and PRIOR id =  id 
      and PRIOR SYS_GUID() is not null  
   order by id, level;

If you want an "ANSIer" approach go with a CTE:

with t (id,res,val,lev) as (
           select id, trim(regexp_substr(value,'[^,]+', 1, 1 )) res, value as val, 1 as lev
             from tbl1
            where regexp_substr(value, '[^,]+', 1, 1) is not null
            union all           
            select id, trim(regexp_substr(val,'[^,]+', 1, lev+1) ) res, val, lev+1 as lev
              from t
              where regexp_substr(val, '[^,]+', 1, lev+1) is not null
              )
select id, res,lev
  from t
order by id, lev;

OUTPUT

id  val lev
1   AA  1
1   UT  2
1   BT  3
1   SK  4
1   SX  5
2   AA  1
2   UT  2
2   SX  3
3   UT  1
3   SK  2
3   SX  3
3   ZF  4

Another recursive approach by MT0 but without regex:

WITH t ( id, value, start_pos, end_pos ) AS
  ( SELECT id, value, 1, INSTR( value, ',' ) FROM tbl1
  UNION ALL
  SELECT id,
    value,
    end_pos                    + 1,
    INSTR( value, ',', end_pos + 1 )
  FROM t
  WHERE end_pos > 0
  )
SELECT id,
  SUBSTR( value, start_pos, DECODE( end_pos, 0, LENGTH( value ) + 1, end_pos ) - start_pos ) AS value
FROM t
ORDER BY id,
  start_pos;

I've tried 3 approaches with a 30000 rows dataset and 118104 rows returned and got the following average results:

• My recursive approach: 5 seconds
• MT0 approach: 4 seconds
• Mathguy approach: 16 seconds
• MT0 recursive approach no-regex: 3.45 seconds

@Mathguy has also tested with a bigger dataset:

In all cases the recursive query (I only tested the one with regular substr and instr) does better, by a factor of 2 to 5. Here are the combinations of # of strings / tokens per string and CTAS execution times for hierarchical vs. recursive, hierarchical first. All times in seconds

• 30,000 x 4: 5 / 1.
• 30,000 x 10: 15 / 3.
• 30,000 x 25: 56 / 37.
• 5,000 x 50: 33 / 14.
• 5,000 x 100: 160 / 81.
• 10,000 x 200: 1,924 / 772

Answer 2

This will get the values without requiring you to remove duplicates or having to use a hack of including SYS_GUID() or DBMS_RANDOM.VALUE() in the CONNECT BY:

SELECT t.id,
       v.COLUMN_VALUE AS value
FROM   TBL1 t,
       TABLE(
         CAST(
           MULTISET(
             SELECT TRIM( REGEXP_SUBSTR( t.value, '[^,]+', 1, LEVEL ) )
             FROM   DUAL
             CONNECT BY LEVEL <= REGEXP_COUNT( t.value, '[^,]+' )
           )
           AS SYS.ODCIVARCHAR2LIST
         )
       ) v

Update:

Returning the index of the element in the list:

Option 1 - Return a UDT:

CREATE TYPE string_pair IS OBJECT( lvl INT, value VARCHAR2(4000) );
/

CREATE TYPE string_pair_table IS TABLE OF string_pair;
/

SELECT t.id,
       v.*
FROM   TBL1 t,
       TABLE(
         CAST(
           MULTISET(
             SELECT string_pair( level, TRIM( REGEXP_SUBSTR( t.value, '[^,]+', 1, LEVEL ) ) )
             FROM   DUAL
             CONNECT BY LEVEL <= REGEXP_COUNT( t.value, '[^,]+' )
           )
           AS string_pair_table
         )
       ) v;

Option 2 - Use ROW_NUMBER():

SELECT t.id,
       v.COLUMN_VALUE AS value,
       ROW_NUMBER() OVER ( PARTITION BY id ORDER BY ROWNUM ) AS lvl
FROM   TBL1 t,
       TABLE(
         CAST(
           MULTISET(
             SELECT TRIM( REGEXP_SUBSTR( t.value, '[^,]+', 1, LEVEL ) )
             FROM   DUAL
             CONNECT BY LEVEL <= REGEXP_COUNT( t.value, '[^,]+' )
           )
           AS SYS.ODCIVARCHAR2LIST
         )
       ) v;