How to check that a uri string is valid

Question

How do you check that a uri string is valid (that you can feed it to the Uri constructor)?

So far I only have the following but for obvious reasons I'd prefer a less brute way:

    Boolean IsValidUri(String uri)     {         try         {             new Uri(uri);             return true;         }         catch         {             return false;         }     } 

I tried Uri.IsWellFormedUriString but it doesn't seem to like everything that you can throw at the constructor. For example:

String test = @"C:\File.txt"; Console.WriteLine("Uri.IsWellFormedUriString says: {0}", Uri.IsWellFormedUriString(test, UriKind.RelativeOrAbsolute)); Console.WriteLine("IsValidUri says: {0}", IsValidUri(test)); 

The output will be:

Uri.IsWellFormedUriString says: False IsValidUri says: True 

Update/Answer

The Uri constructor uses kind Absolute by default. This was causing a discrepancy when I tried using Uri.TryCreate and the constructor. You do get the expected outcome if you match the UriKind for both the constructor and TryCreate.

Answer 1

A well-formed URI implies conformance with certain RFCs. The local path in your example is not conformant with these. Read more in the IsWellFormedUriString documentation.

A false result from that method does not imply that the Uri class will not be able to parse the input. While the URI input might not be RFC conformant, it still can be a valid URI.

Update: And to answer your question - as the Uri documentation shows, there is a static method called TryCreate that will attempt exactly what you want and return true or false (and the actual Uri instance if true).