How do I view grants on Redshift

Question

I'd like to view grants on redshifts.

I found this view for postgres:

CREATE OR REPLACE VIEW view_all_grants AS 
SELECT 
  use.usename as subject, 
  nsp.nspname as namespace, 
  c.relname as item, 
  c.relkind as type, 
  use2.usename as owner, 
  c.relacl, 
  (use2.usename != use.usename and c.relacl::text !~ ('({|,)' || use.usename || '=')) as public
FROM 
  pg_user use 
  cross join pg_class c 
  left join pg_namespace nsp on (c.relnamespace = nsp.oid) 
  left join pg_user use2 on (c.relowner = use2.usesysid)
WHERE 
  c.relowner = use.usesysid or 
  c.relacl::text ~ ('({|,)(|' || use.usename || ')=') 
ORDER BY 
  subject, 
  namespace, 
  item 

Which doesn't work because the ::text cast of relacl fails with the following:

ERROR: cannot cast type aclitem[] to character varying [SQL State=42846] 

Modifying the query to

CREATE OR REPLACE VIEW view_all_grants AS 
SELECT 
  use.usename as subject, 
  nsp.nspname as namespace, 
  c.relname as item, 
  c.relkind as type, 
  use2.usename as owner, 
  c.relacl 
  -- , (use2.usename != use.usename and c.relacl::text !~ ('({|,)' || use.usename || '=')) as public
FROM 
  pg_user use 
  cross join pg_class c 
  left join pg_namespace nsp on (c.relnamespace = nsp.oid) 
  left join pg_user use2 on (c.relowner = use2.usesysid)
WHERE 
  c.relowner = use.usesysid 
  -- or c.relacl::text ~ ('({|,)(|' || use.usename || ')=') 
ORDER BY 
  subject, 
  namespace, 
  item 

Allows the view to be created, but I'm concerned that this is not showing all relevant data.

How can I modify the view to work on redshift or is there an better/alternative way to view grants on redshift ?

UPDATE: Redshift has the HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE function to check grants. (see here)

Answer 1

Another variation be like:

SELECT *  FROM      (     SELECT          schemaname         ,objectname         ,usename         ,HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, fullobj, 'select') AND has_schema_privilege(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'usage')  AS sel         ,HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, fullobj, 'insert') AND has_schema_privilege(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'usage')  AS ins         ,HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, fullobj, 'update') AND has_schema_privilege(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'usage')  AS upd         ,HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, fullobj, 'delete') AND has_schema_privilege(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'usage')  AS del         ,HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, fullobj, 'references') AND has_schema_privilege(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'usage')  AS ref     FROM         (         SELECT schemaname, 't' AS obj_type, tablename AS objectname, schemaname + '.' + tablename AS fullobj FROM pg_tables         WHERE schemaname not in ('pg_internal')         UNION         SELECT schemaname, 'v' AS obj_type, viewname AS objectname, schemaname + '.' + viewname AS fullobj FROM pg_views         WHERE schemaname not in ('pg_internal')         ) AS objs         ,(SELECT * FROM pg_user) AS usrs     ORDER BY fullobj     ) WHERE (sel = true or ins = true or upd = true or del = true or ref = true) and schemaname='<opt schema>' and usename = '<opt username>'; 

Answer 2

Something along the lines off:

select tablename,     HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(tablename, 'select') as select,    HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(tablename, 'insert') as insert,    HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(tablename, 'update') as update,    HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(tablename, 'delete') as delete,     HAS_TABLE_PRIVILEGE(tablename, 'references') as references  from pg_tables where schemaname='public' order by tablename; 

gives me all I need.

Answer 3

A development on the answer from mike_pdb I came up with the following

 WITH object_list(schema_name,object_name,permission_info)
 AS (
    SELECT N.nspname, C.relname, array_to_string(relacl,',')
    FROM pg_class AS C
        INNER JOIN pg_namespace AS N
        ON C.relnamespace = N.oid
    WHERE C.relkind in ('v','r')
    AND  N.nspname NOT IN ('pg_catalog', 'pg_toast', 'information_schema')
    AND C.relacl[1] IS NOT NULL
  ),
  object_permissions(schema_name,object_name,permission_string)
  AS (
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',1) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',2) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',3) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',4) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',5) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',6) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',7) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',8) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',9) FROM object_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,object_name, SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',10) FROM object_list
  ),
  permission_parts(schema_name, object_name,security_principal, permission_pattern)
  AS (
      SELECT
          schema_name,
          object_name,
          LEFT(permission_string ,CHARINDEX('=',permission_string)-1),
          SPLIT_PART(SPLIT_PART(permission_string,'=',2),'/',1)
      FROM object_permissions
      WHERE permission_string >''
  )
SELECT
    schema_name,
    object_name,
    'GRANT ' ||
    SUBSTRING(
        case when charindex('r',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',SELECT ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('w',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',UPDATE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('a',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',INSERT ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('d',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',DELETE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('R',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',RULE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('x',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',REFERENCES ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('t',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',TRIGGER ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('X',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',EXECUTE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('U',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',USAGE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('C',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',CREATE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('T',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',TEMPORARY ' else '' end
    ,2,10000
    )
    || ' ON ' || schema_name||'.'||object_name
     || ' TO ' || security_principal
     || ';' as grantsql
FROM permission_parts

;

There are 3 common table expressions used here.

• object_list - Tables and views with their permissions array as a comma delimited string.
• object_permissions - schema/object (table or view) and a record per permission string. Note that the SPLIT_PART function does not allow a dynamic part position so the assumption here is that there are no more than 10 users or groups assigned direct permissions
• permission_parts The schema/object, security principal to whom permissions are granted and the security attributes that are set.

As per mike_pdb's solution the individual permission characters are converted into a concatenated list of grants. As we don't which grants will be used we use SUBSTRING from position 2 to discard the first comma in the list.

You can use exactly the same approach for scripting off schema permissions

WITH schema_list(schema_name, permission_info)
AS (
    SELECT nspname, array_to_string(nspacl,',')
    FROM pg_namespace
    WHERE nspacl[1] IS NOT NULL
    AND nspname NOT LIKE 'pg%' AND nspname NOT IN ('public','information_schema')
),
schema_permissions(schema_name,permission_string)
AS (
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',1) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',2) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',3) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',4) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',5) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',6) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',7) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',8) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',9) FROM schema_list
    UNION ALL
    SELECT schema_name,SPLIT_PART(permission_info,',',10) FROM schema_list
),
permission_parts(schema_name, security_principal, permission_pattern)
AS (
    SELECT
        schema_name,
        LEFT(permission_string ,CHARINDEX('=',permission_string)-1),
        SPLIT_PART(SPLIT_PART(permission_string,'=',2),'/',1)
    FROM schema_permissions
    WHERE permission_string >''
)
SELECT
    schema_name,
    'GRANT ' ||
    SUBSTRING(
        case when charindex('r',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',SELECT ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('w',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',UPDATE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('a',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',INSERT ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('d',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',DELETE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('R',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',RULE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('x',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',REFERENCES ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('t',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',TRIGGER ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('X',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',EXECUTE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('U',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',USAGE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('C',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',CREATE ' else '' end
      ||case when charindex('T',permission_pattern) > 0 then ',TEMPORARY ' else '' end
    ,2,10000
    )
    || ' ON SCHEMA ' || schema_name
     || ' TO ' || security_principal
     || ';' as grantsql
FROM permission_parts;

Answer 4

The has_table_privilege function is handy, but doesn't always help in administration when you want to manage groups. I morphed your original query to create grant scripts for specific users or groups. This sample query can be easily morphed to accommodate your needs

select namespace||'.'||item as tablename , 
'grant ' || substring(
                case when charindex('r',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',select ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('w',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',update ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('a',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',insert ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('d',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',delete ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('R',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',rule ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('x',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',references ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('t',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',trigger ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('X',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',execute ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('U',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',usage ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('C',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',create ' else '' end 
              ||case when charindex('T',split_part(split_part(array_to_string(relacl, '|'),'group dw_developers=',2 ) ,'/',1)) > 0 then ',temporary ' else '' end 
           , 2,10000)
 || ' on '||namespace||'.'||item ||' to group dw_developers;' as grantsql
from 
(SELECT 
  use.usename as subject, 
  nsp.nspname as namespace, 
  c.relname as item, 
  c.relkind as type, 
  use2.usename as owner, 
  c.relacl 
 FROM 
  pg_user use 
  cross join pg_class c 
  left join pg_namespace nsp on (c.relnamespace = nsp.oid) 
  left join pg_user use2 on (c.relowner = use2.usesysid)
 WHERE 
  c.relowner = use.usesysid  
  and  nsp.nspname NOT IN ('pg_catalog', 'pg_toast', 'information_schema')
 ORDER BY 
  subject,   namespace,   item 
 ) where relacl is not null
 and array_to_string(relacl, '|') like '%group dw_developers%' order by 1

Answer 5

Here is another useful query to view grants on schema (usage, create) by user that I created based on the query above by @drtf:

SELECT * 
FROM 
    (
    SELECT 
        schemaname
        ,usename
        ,HAS_SCHEMA_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'usage') AS usg
        ,HAS_SCHEMA_PRIVILEGE(usrs.usename, schemaname, 'create') AS crt
    FROM
        (
        SELECT distinct(schemaname) FROM pg_tables
        WHERE schemaname not in ('pg_internal')
        UNION
        SELECT distinct(schemaname) FROM pg_views
        WHERE schemaname not in ('pg_internal')
        ) AS objs
        ,(SELECT * FROM pg_user) AS usrs
    ORDER BY schemaname
    )
WHERE (usg = true or crt = true)
--and schemaname='<opt schemaname>'
--and usename = '<opt username>';