Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

How can I fix the Kerberos double-hop issue?

I'm having some trouble calling a web service from within a web application and I was hoping someone here might be able to help. From what I can tell, this seems to have something to do with the Kerberos double-hop issue. However, if it is, I'm not sure what to do to actually fix the problem. To make things harder, I don't have the proper permissions to make changes to Active Directory accounts, so I need to know what to ask for when requesting changes. In my situation, I need to pass the credentials (Integrated Windows Authentication) from a web application onto a backend web service so that the web service runs under the proper user context.

Here's my exact issue:

This works

Working scenario

This doesn't work

Non-working scenario

The only difference between the working scenario and the non-working scenario is that the working scenario is running the application on localhost (whether a developer's PC or on the server in question) and the non-working example is running on another machine. The code between both scenarios is exactly the same.

What I've tried

  1. Adding an SPN to the domain account that runs the app pool for each server setspn -a http/server1 DOMAIN\account
  2. Different methods of impersonation
  3. Removing the impersonation code using(...) and executing the web service call as the app pool account. This works as expected.

Does anyone have any idea on what I might be able to do in order to fix this problem?

like image 753
Steve Platz Avatar asked Feb 18 '13 01:02

Steve Platz


People also ask

How do you resolve Kerberos problems?

Resolution. To resolve this problem, update the registry on each computer that participates in the Kerberos authentication process, including the client computers. We recommend that you update all of your Windows-based systems, especially if your users have to log on across multiple domains or forests.

What is Kerberos double hop?

Kerberos Double Hop is a term used to describe our method of maintaining the client's Kerberos authentication credentials over two or more connections. In this fashion we can retain the user's credentials and act on behalf of the user in further connections to other servers.

What is double hop issue?

Double hop issues are when you have a client connect to one SQL Server and that server needs to pull data from another SQL Server. The first server uses Windows Authentication credentials on the second server and the connection to the first SQL Server is made using Kerberos authentication.

How do I enable Kerberos authentication in edge?

For Google Chrome and Microsoft Edge on Windows, Kerberos authentication is configured in general settings of the operating system: Go to Control Panel and select Internet Options > Advanced. On the Advanced tab and in the Security section, select Enable Integrated Windows Authentication (requires restart).


2 Answers

The intermediate server must be trusted for delegation. Otherwise no credential will be delegated and the intermediate server cannot impersonate the original client.

like image 180
Michael-O Avatar answered Sep 22 '22 16:09

Michael-O


More often than not the reason is that Server 1 does not pass a delegation token to Server 2. So when Server 2 tries to use that authentication ticket to go somewhere else (probably a SQL server) it fails.

You should set the impersonation level for the WCF call

ClientCredentials.Windows.AllowedImpersonationLevel = TokenImpersonationLevel.Delegation 

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/system.servicemodel.security.windowsclientcredential.allowedimpersonationlevel.aspx

like image 23
Knaģis Avatar answered Sep 19 '22 16:09

Knaģis