GoogleApiClient is throwing "GoogleApiClient is not connected yet" AFTER onConnected function getting called

Question

So I found something that is not very clear for me about GoogleApiClient. GoogleApiClient has a function called onConnected which is run when the client is connected (for sure).

I got my own function called: startLocationListening which is eventually getting called on GoogleApiClient's onConnected function.

So my startLocationListening function couldn't run without a GoogleApiClient connection.

Code and log:

@Override
public void onConnected(Bundle bundle) {
    log("Google_Api_Client:connected.");
    initLocationRequest();
    startLocationListening(); //Exception caught inside this function
}

...

private void startLocationListening() {
    log("Starting_location_listening:now");

    //Exception caught here below:
    LocationServices.FusedLocationApi.requestLocationUpdates(mGoogleApiClient, mLocationRequest, this);
   }

The exception is:

03-30 12:23:28.947: E/AndroidRuntime(4936):     java.lang.IllegalStateException: GoogleApiClient is not connected yet.
03-30 12:23:28.947: E/AndroidRuntime(4936):     at com.google.android.gms.internal.jx.a(Unknown Source)
03-30 12:23:28.947: E/AndroidRuntime(4936):     at com.google.android.gms.common.api.c.b(Unknown Source)
03-30 12:23:28.947: E/AndroidRuntime(4936):     at com.google.android.gms.internal.nf.requestLocationUpdates(Unknown Source)
03-30 12:23:28.947: E/AndroidRuntime(4936):     at hu.company.testproject.service.GpsService.startLocationListening(GpsService.java:169)
03-30 12:23:28.947: E/AndroidRuntime(4936):     at hu.company.testproject.service.GpsService.onConnected(GpsService.java:259)

...

My debug log also says the onConnected function got called:

03-30 12:23:28.847: I/Locationing_GpsService(4936): Google_Api_Client:connected.
03-30 12:23:28.857: I/Locationing_GpsService(4936): initLocationRequest:initing_now
03-30 12:23:28.877: I/Locationing_GpsService(4936): initLocationRequest:interval_5000
03-30 12:23:28.897: I/Locationing_GpsService(4936): initLocationRequest:priority_100
03-30 12:23:28.917: I/Locationing_GpsService(4936): Starting_location_listening:now

After this I got the exception.

Am I missing something here? I got a response for "connected" I ran my func, and I got the error "not connected" what's this? Plus one annoying thing is: I used this location service for weeks now and never got this error.

E D I T :

I added a more specific log output, just blown my mind, check this out:

@Override
    public void onConnected(Bundle bundle) {

        if(mGoogleApiClient.isConnected()){
            log("Google_Api_Client: It was connected on (onConnected) function, working as it should.");
        }
        else{
            log("Google_Api_Client: It was NOT connected on (onConnected) function, It is definetly bugged.");
        }

        initLocationRequest();
        startLocationListening();
    }

log output in this case:

03-30 16:20:00.950: I/Locationing_GpsService(16608): Google_Api_Client:connected.
03-30 16:20:00.960: I/Locationing_GpsService(16608): Google_Api_Client: It was NOT connected on (onConnected) function, It is definetly bugged.

Yes, I just got mGoogleApiClient.isConnected() == false inside onConnected() how is it possible?

E D I T:

Since nobody could answer this even with reputation bounty, I decided to report this as a bug to Google. What came next was really surprising to me. Google's official answer for my report:

"This website is for developer issues with the AOSP Android source code and the developer toolset, not Google apps or services such as Play services, GMS or Google APIs. Unfortunately there doesn't seem to be an appropriate place to report bugs with Play Services. All I can say is that this website isn't it, sorry. Try posting on the Google Product Forums instead. "

Full issue report here. (I hope they won't remove it just because it's silly)

So yeah I took a look at Google Product Forums and just couldn't find any topic to post this thing, so at the moment I am puzzled and stuck.

Does anybody in planet earth could help me with this?

E D I T:

Full code in pastebin

Answer 1

I just noticed that you are creating the googleApiClient in onStartCommand(). This seems like a bad idea.

Let's say that your service gets triggered twice. Two googleApiClient objects will get created, but you'll only have reference to one. If the one whose reference you don't have executes its callback to onConnected(), you will be connected in that client but the client whose reference you actually do have could still be unconnected.

I suspect that's what's going on. Try moving your googleApiClient creation to onCreate and see if you get the same behavior.

Answer 2

I had the same error, but my problem was different from iheanyl's answer:

I had declared the googleApiClient static. This prevented android from shutting down the service.

Answer 3

I had this problem to and I solved it with declaring googleApiClient as static object