git setup for multiple repos on same server

Question

Probably a simple question, but I am at a loss here...

In github one can add a deployment key for each repository which only gives access to that single repository.

But for one client I have two projects managed with git on the same server (project A and project B). If I use the public key for project A, github tells me I cant use it as a deployment key for project B and vice versa.

How can I create another public key and setup git to use one key for project A and the other one for project B?

Answer 1

The ssh way to do this would be using ~/.ssh/config, creating a hostname alias and accessing github with different hostnames for both projects. I have no idea whether there is a git config (or git remote) way too.

Host a.github.com HostName github.com User git IdentityFile ~/.ssh/project-a-id_rsa  Host b.github.com HostName github.com User git IdentityFile ~/.ssh/project-b-id_rsa 

Then use a.github.com:user/project-a.git or b.github.com:user/project-b.git (or similar) as your repository URLs.

Answer 2

Let's say alice is a github.com user, with 2 or more private repositories repoN. For this example we'll work with just two repositories named repo1 and repo2

https://github.com/alice/repo1

https://github.com/alice/repo2

You need to be to pull from these repositories without entering a passwords probably on a server, or on multiple servers. You want to perform git pull origin master for example, and you want this to happen without asking for a password.

You don't like dealing with ssh-agent, you have discovered (or you're discovering now) about ~/.ssh/config a file that let's your ssh client know what private key to use depending on Hostname and username, with a simple configuration entry that looks like this:

Host github.com   HostName github.com   User git   IdentityFile /home/alice/.ssh/alice_github.id_rsa   IdentitiesOnly yes 

So you went ahead and created your (alice_github.id_rsa, alice_github.id_rsa.pub) keypair, you then also went to your repository's .git/config file and you modified the url of your remote origin to be something like this:

[remote "origin"]         url = "ssh://[email protected]/alice/repo1.git" 

And finally you went to the repository Settings > Deploy keys section and added the contents of alice_github.id_rsa.pub

At this point you could do your git pull origin master without entering a password without issue.

but what about the second repository?

So your instinct will be to grab that key and add it to repo2's Deploy keys, but github.com will error out and tell you that the key is already being used.

Now you go and generate another key (using ssh-keygen -t rsa -C "[email protected]" without passwords of course), and so that this doesn't become a mess, you will now name your keys like this:

• repo1 keypair: (repo1.alice_github.id_rsa, repo1.alice_github.id_rsa.pub)
• repo2 keypair: (repo2.alice_github.id_rsa, repo2.alice_github.id_rsa.pub)

You will now put the new public key on repo2's Deploy keys configuration at github.com, but now you have an ssh problem to deal with.

How can ssh tell which key to use if the repositories are hosted on the same github.com domain?

Your .ssh/config file points to github.com and it doesn't know which key to use when it's time to do the pull.

So I found a trick with github.com. You can tell your ssh client that each repository lives in a different github.com subdomain, in these cases, they will be repo1.github.com and repo2.github.com

So first thing is editing the .git/config files on your repo clones, so they look like this instead:

For repo1

[remote "origin"]         url = "ssh://[email protected]/alice/repo1.git" 

For repo2

[remote "origin"] url = "ssh://[email protected]/alice/repo2.git"

And then, on your .ssh/config file, now you will be able to enter a configuration for each subdomain :)

Host repo1.github.com   HostName github.com   User git   IdentityFile /home/alice/.ssh/repo1.alice_github.id_rsa   IdentitiesOnly yes  Host repo2.github.com   HostName github.com   User git   IdentityFile /home/alice/.ssh/repo2.alice_github.id_rsa   IdentitiesOnly yes 

Now you are able to git pull origin master without entering any passwords from both repositories.

If you have multiple machines, you could copy the keys to each of the machines and reuse them, but I'd advise doing the leg work to generate 1 key per machine and repo. You will have a lot more keys to handle, but you will be less vulnerable if one gets compromised.