Find malloc() array length in C? [duplicate]

Question

Possible Duplicate:
How to find the sizeof(a pointer pointing to an array)

I'm learning how to create a dynamic array in C, but have come across an issue I can't figure out.

If I use the code:

int num[10]; for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) {     num[i] = i; } printf("sizeof num = %li\n sizeof num[0] = %li", sizeof(num), sizeof(num[0])); 

I get the output:

sizeof num = 40 sizeof num[0] = 4 

This is what I'd expect to happen. However if I malloc the size of the array like:

int *num; num = malloc(10 * sizeof(int)); for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) {     num[i] = i; } printf("sizeof num = %li\n sizeof num[0] = %li", sizeof(num), sizeof(num[0])); 

Then I get the output:

sizeof num = 8 sizeof num[0] = 4 

I'm curious to know why the size of the array is 40 when I use the fixed length method, but not when I use malloc().

Answer 1

In the second case, num is not an array, is a pointer. sizeof is giving you the size of the pointer, which seems to be 8 bytes on your platform.

There is no way to know the size of a dynamically allocated array, you have to save it somewhere else. sizeof looks at the type, but you can't obtain a complete array type (array type with a specified size, like the type int[5]) from the result of malloc in any way, and sizeof argument can't be applied to an incomplete type, like int[].

Answer 2

Arrays are not pointers (the decay to pointers in some situations, not here).

The first one is an array - so sizeof gives you the size of the array = 40 bytes.

The second is a pointer (irrespective of how many elements it points to) - sizeof gives you sizeof(int*).