F# fslex fsyacc mature for production code?

Question

After reading a 2 year old webpage really ripping fslex/fsyacc, buggy, slow, stupid etc. compared to their OCamel counterparts i wonder what would be ones best bet for lexing parsing needs?

Ive used ANTLR before with C# bindings but am currently in the process of learning F# and was excited when i saw it came with a parser generator. Since F# is now officaly released and it seems something Microsoft is really aiming to support and develop. Would you say fslex and fsyacc is worth it for production code?

Answer 1

Fslex and fsyacc are used by the F# compiler, so they kind of work. I have used them a few years ago, it was good enough for my needs.

However, my experience is that lex/yacc is much less mature in F# than in OCaml. Many people in the OCaml community have used them for years, including many students (it seems like writing a small interpreter/compiler with them is a common exercise). I don't think many F# developers have used them, and I don't think the F# team has done a lot of work on these tools recently (for instance, VS integration has not been a priority). If you're not very exigent, Fslex and fsyacc could be enough for you.

A solution could be to adapt Menhir (a camlyacc replacement with several nice features) to use it with F#. I have no idea how much work it would be.

Personally, I now use FParsec every time I need to write a parser. It's quite different to use, but it's also much more flexible and it generates good parse error messages. I've been very happy with it and its author has always been very helpful when I had questions.