Extending enum in derived classes [duplicate]

Question

I have a class hierarchy, and each class in it has an exception class, derived in a parallel hierarchy, thus...

class Base
{
};

class Derived : public Base
{
};

class BaseException : public std::exception
{
   enum {THIS_REASON, THAT_REASON};
};

class DerivedException : public BaseException
{
    // er...what?
};

I would like, in the DerivedException class, to extend the enumeration type to include a new value THE_OTHER_REASON, so that the DerivedException class could hold any of the three values.

First of all, ought I to want to do this? Does it seem a reasonable practice? If so, how do I go about it? If not, what alternatives would you recommend?

EDIT: A possible duplicate has been suggested here, but the suggested solutions are different because that question is for C# and this for C++.

Answer 1

From the OO standpoint, it is not reasonable. Since you say that DerivedException is-a BaseException, its possible reasons must be a subset of that of BaseException, not a superset. Otherwise you ultimately break the Liskov Substitution Principle.

Moreover, since C++ enums are not classes, you can't extend or inherit them. You can define additional reasons in a separate enum within DerivedException, but then ultimately you bump into the same problem described above:

class DerivedException : public BaseException
{
  enum {
    SOME_OTHER_REASON = THAT_REASON + 256, // allow extensions in the base enum
    AND_ANOTHER_REASON
  };
  ...
};

...
try {
  ...
} catch (BaseException& ex) {
  if (ex.getReason() == BaseException::THIS_REASON)
    ...
  else if (ex.getReason() == BaseException::THAT_REASON)
    ...
  else if (ex.getReason() == ??? what to test for here ???)
    ...
}

What you can do instead is define a separate exception subclass for each distinct reason. Then you can handle them polymorphically (if needed). This is the approach of the standard C++ library as well as other class libraries. Thus you adhere to the conventions, which makes your code easier to understand.